Even Pickler would have kicked butt this year.
I don’t think Kelli Pickler was better than Jordin.
I liked Pickler...but, I don’t think she was better.
I do think that this group has the least “range”...IOW, they all had a “style” and it was hard for them to change, even when the genre for the week called for it.
Melinda’s songs seemed to sound alike...as did Blake’s (beatbox)...and Jordin to an extent.
Phil was a surprise..when he sang CW..he shined, even though he didn’t present himself as CW.