I fully understand that you're uncomfortable arguing with someone who actually knows something about the subject of your uninformed rants.
BTW, you haven't shared where, in what field and when you got your Ph.D.. Given that you've appointed yourself an arbiter of who's a real scientist and mathematician, it must be somewhere really good. Maybe you're in the National Academy?
"Maybe you're in the National Academy?"
Those National Academy people always were a group of elitists.