What do I care, I don't support teaching ID in science classes.
I just don't like seeing judges make stupid laws into constitutional issues. We have a constitutional right to have stupid laws. We can vote out the people who write stupid laws.
Note that the Dover school board members who started this were all voted out of office. I would imagine that the new school board would have thrown out this policy without any bidding from an activist court.
The judge in this case was assigned randomly. He didn't bring the lawsuit, all he did was judge it according to the existing precedents.
I disagree with those precedents, but that's another story entirely.