may I offer another solution? I moderate at another forum, a Christian forum, and when thing get a little too heated for the forum and posters want an arena that is less stringent on rules of debate and decorum, I usually suggest they take it to a private forum they set up themselves.
There are lots of free ones available, though often the formats leave a lot to be desired.
That might be a remedy at this time.
This is an excellent idea, especially considering what FreeRepublic has been through recently.
Though I will say that since the Pope was able to forgive his would-be assassin, surely FReepers can put an end to the rancor and forgive each other.
Bump to your last sentence especially.