Was Whoopi Goldberg Right that Hitler Was a Christian?: A Historical Analysis

Townhall.com ^ | November 25, 2015 | Richard Weikhart

[Kaslin]

Whatever one thinks about the controversy over Syrian refugees and ISIS, Whoopi Goldberg's recent comments on national television trying to convince us that Christian refugees are just as scary as Muslims disseminates an idea that circulates widely on the internet, i.e., that Hitler was a Christian. She stated, "There have been a lot of horrifying there have been a lot of monster Christians. Hitler was a Christian." When her interlocutors balked at this, she then defended her position by saying, "He didn't like the Catholics, remember? So he thought of himself as a Christian person." Goldberg apparently doesn't understand that Catholicism is a branch of Christianity, or that Hitler despite his opposition to Catholicism was officially a Catholic.

If Goldberg were the only one confused about Hitler's relationship to Christianity, we could ignore it. However, she was expressing a view that circulates widely, especially in atheist circles. Leading atheist intellectuals, such as Richard Dawkins, have insisted that Hitler was a sincere Christian. Their evidence? He said so himself in some of his speeches in the 1920s. In one famous quote circulating on dozens of atheist websites, Hitler stated (on April 12, 1922), "My Christian feeling directs me to my Lord and Savior as a fighter. As a Christian I do not have the duty to allow the wool to be pulled over my eyes, but I have the duty to be a fighter for the truth and for what is right. As a Christian I also have a duty toward my own people (Volk)."

Strangely, those trumpeting this quotation as proof that Hitler was indeed a Christian display the attitude: Hitler said it, I believe it, and that settles it. Never does it seem to cross their minds that Hitler might be gasp lying for political advantage. They are as convinced of Hitler's veracity as the naïve British Prime Minister Chamberlain was when he arrived back from the Munich Conference waving a sheet of paper with Hitler's signature on it and proclaiming: "It is peace for our time." In short, they gullibly swallow Hitler's propaganda (and they blithely ignore a plethora of Hitler's anti-Christian remarks).

Fortunately, my forthcoming book, Hitler's Religion: The Twisted Beliefs That Drove the Third Reich (2016) will definitively lay to rest the canard that Hitler was a Christian. By examining in painstaking detail Hitler's writings, speeches, private conversations, and the testimony of his colleagues, I demonstrate that Hitler’s worldview was far more anti-Christian than Christian. For one thing, there is powerful evidence that Hitler purposely lied about his religious convictions. For instance, when Hitler was in Landsberg Prison, his right-hand man, Rudolf Hess, wrote in a confidential letter that Hitler told him that, as painful as it was for him, "for reasons of political expediency he [Hitler] had to play the hypocrite toward his church."

Secondly, Hitler often made anti-Christian remarks to his private entourage, and even occasionally slipped in some anti-Christian comments in his public writings and speeches.  Hitler not only abhorred the Old Testament of the Christian Bible as Jewish, but he rejected most of the New Testament, especially the epistles of Paul, whom he considered a sneaky Jewish rabbi who smuggled Jewish ideas into Christianity. To be sure, Hitler did esteem Jesus highly, because he thought Jesus was an Aryan antisemitic fighter fathered by a Roman solider (thus not the Son of God born of a virgin). His favorite Bible story, as he told it, was when Jesus wielded a whip to drive those money-grubbing Jews out of the temple. Hitler clearly did not believe in Jesus's resurrection, claiming that Jesus's life ended in failure, since he was martyred by the Jews.

Almost from the beginning of his political career to the end, Hitler portrayed Christianity as a tool of the Jews that supplanted the Greco-Roman culture that he loved. He continually complained that Christianity was still imbued with a Jewish spirit. He remonstrated against Christian morality, especially its exaltation of humility and compassion for the sick and weak.

On the other hand, Hitler held in the highest esteem anti-Christian philosophers, such as Schopenhauer and Nietzsche. Hitler even donated his own personal funds to the Nietzsche Archive to promote the ideas of this God-is-dead philosopher. Hitler also expressed admiration for the religious views of Frederick the Great, who was a patron of such Enlightenment luminaries as the deist Voltaire and the atheist La Mettrie.

In sum, Hitler remained officially a Catholic throughout his life, and he esteemed Jesus highly. However, he denied that Jesus was God and ridiculed Christian doctrines, rejected the Christian holy book, and hated Christian moral standards.  In one diatribe in 1941 he stated, "Christianity is the most insane thing that a human brain in its delusion has ever brought forth, a mockery of everything divine."

[Kaslin]

Please note that Hitler was Austrian, not German.

[bert]

also note that Whoopi is black not white

[MayflowerMadam]

Well, there’s big-C “Christian”, and little-C “Christian”. Maybe he was a Christian (not Jewish, Muslim, etc.), but he certainly wasn’t a Christian (Christ-like - born again).

[MayflowerMadam]

Well, I see that auto-correct changed my lower-case c to upper case c a couple of times. Damn computers trying to think for me!!

[xp38]

Exactly. One could say the same about Stalin. His mother sent him on a scholarship to an Orthodox seminary but Stalin says he became an athiest in his first year there.

[pieceofthepuzzle]

I wasn’t saying it was Christian reasoning, but that the majority of allied soldiers where Christian. My point is that it wasn’t Christian reasoning that was supporting Hitler, or being used by Hitler as a tool. On the other hand, Islam is being used as the reason for the existence of ISIS, and a fair percentage of Muslims support the concept. This is the problem, and this is the difference - and why Whoopi’s comments are not germane. Plus, the Mufti Haj Amin al-Husseini met with Hitler to extend the anti-Jewish program.

[Retain Mike]

Thanks.

[samtheman]

Liberals lie. That is what they do. They lie about everything. Past. Present. Future.

[Cronos]

Hitler saw the Austrians as part of the Germanic peoples -- which they are. The only reasons Austria is not part of Germany are:

1. Prussia unified the various Germanic nations (Swabia, Saxony, Bayern etc.) and not the Habsburgs
2. At the end of WWI, the Austrians wanted to join with Germany but the allies did not allow it.

Germanic peoples include Austrians and Dutch and northern Swiss and indeed the Scandinavians with common mythologies which Hitler wanted to revive

[RipSawyer]

It is hardly surprising that some of the same people who believe that Obama is a Christian would believe that Hitler was a Christian.

[Cronos]

Sorry Hugin, but that's only partly true and the rest of PC embellishment

Christian European countries conquered most of the world, but only the Spanish and the Portuguese made much effort to bring people to Christianity.

In terms of "murdered a lot of people" -- remember that the majority of people killed in the Americas and Australia were due to diseases brought over inadvertently by the explorers

[lentulusgracchus]

Which kind of sums it all up as far as Hitler's "Christianity" is concerned.

There's a fat coda in the form of hocus-pocus paganism, or should I call it "pseudopaganism"? All that tomb-of-Barbarossa stuff, torchlit ceremonies, and SS-Ahnenerben bullswoggle about a Nazi Proto-German Urheimat around the Externsteine and laughable "Nazi knights" from the Bronze Age, wearing swastikas on their 14th- and 15th-century steel plate-armor. <howling laughter>

Anyway, all this flummery was a big chunk of inside-the-Beltway Nazism back in the day, n/w/s that supposedly one could not enlist in the SS unless one were a professing Christian; atheists were banned.