Posted on 09/30/2015 2:30:00 PM PDT by SeekAndFind
ROME If anyone suspected that Pope Francis didnt really mean the strong words he spoke on religious freedom last week in the United States that he was phoning it in, while his real concerns were elsewhere claims that he held a private meeting with Kentucky county clerk Kim Davis certainly should lay that suspicion to rest.
The meeting was first reported by Robert Moynihan of Inside the Vatican magazine. A Vatican spokesman said Wednesday, I do not deny that the meeting took place, but I have no comments to add, which, in effect, is a way of allowing the report to stand.
Taken together with his unscheduled stop to see the Little Sisters of the Poor, the Davis encounter means Francis has expressed personal support to leading symbols of the two most contentious fronts in Americas religious freedom debates the contraception mandates imposed by the Obama administration, and conscientious objection on gay marriage.
Before unpacking what it means, lets roll out the necessary caveats.
First of all, the fact that someone arranged a brief encounter between Francis and Davis does not necessarily mean that Francis initiated the contact, or even that he necessarily grasps all the dimensions of her case. By her own account it was an extremely brief greeting, just long enough for the pope to tell Davis to stay strong and to give her a rosary. Asking for prayers and offering a blessed rosary to individuals following a meeting is a customary gesture for Pope Francis.
It would be over-interpreting things to read the meeting as a blanket endorsement of everything Davis has said or done.
In addition, we dont yet know how Francis sees the balance between honoring ones conscience and upholding ones responsibilities as a public official, because he hasnt addressed that question at any length.
The fact that the Vatican has chosen not to comment probably means, at least in part, that they dont want to be dragged into a detailed discussion of Davis situation.
That said, theres no way to view the encounter other than as a broad gesture of support by the pope for conscientious objection from gay marriage laws, especially taken in tandem with his statement aboard the papal plane that following ones conscience in such a situation is a human right one, he insisted, that also belongs to government officials.
So what does it mean?
First, it means that Francis has significantly strengthened the hand of the US bishops and other voices in American debates defending religious freedom.
In the wake of a massively successful trip in which Francis was lauded for his stands on issues ranging from climate change to immigration to fighting poverty, it will be more difficult for anyone to wrap themselves in the papal mantle without at least acknowledging his concerns vis-à-vis religious freedom.
Second, Francis may also have smoothed the waters in advance for round two of the Synod of Bishops on the family, which opens on Sunday.
Last time around, the question of how welcoming the Church ought to be to gays and lesbians was a major flashpoint, in part because conservatives worried it might lessen the Churchs resolve to resist a redefinition of marriage. By holding the Davis meeting, Francis has probably reassured conservatives that hes not priming the pump for going soft on same-sex marriage.
Ironically, the Davis meeting may actually increase the odds of the synod recommending a more pastoral approach to same-sex relationships, since there wont be the same fear about where such an opening might lead.
Third, Francis has also debunked impressions of a rift with the American bishops when it comes to the wars of culture.
Yes, Francis called the bishops to spurn harsh and divisive rhetoric and to embrace dialogue as a method. That does not imply, however, that he believes the substance of their concerns is mistaken, and by meeting both the Little Sisters of the Poor and Davis he drove that point home.
Fourth and finally, the Davis meeting confirms that the US trip amounted to the public debut of Francis 2.0, meaning a pope more clearly perceived as standing in continuity with Catholic teaching and tradition, as well as in solidarity both with previous popes and with the bishops.
To put the point in crudely political terms, Francis is a figure who utterly defies the usual left/right divides, equally capable of meeting Kim Davis and embracing poor immigrant children at a Harlem school seeing both as part of a continuum of concern for human dignity.
That will be a source of consolation to some and consternation to others, but in any event its now officially part of the Francis narrative.
The American press sure didn’t run with this.
I also think its strange that our media didn’t report this.
The media gave saturation coverage of the pope’s visit to America. Its surprising that he apparently sneaked away at some point to visit her.
Maybe, and where was his anti Planned Parenthood and anti Radical Islam parts of his speech.
I missed those as well.
It means that Freeper evangelicals are bummed...
I don't know, meeting in secret and in private with her, then avoiding all discussion of it publicly doesn't seem like a ringing endorsement of her cause. Seems like a "I feel your pain" moment and not much more.
He paid a surprise visit to the Little Sisters of the Poor too.
What’s the message? Obama, these people are innocent of sin — leave them alone. Both cases. Call off your lawyers and the ACLU.
That’s ‘cause we have the sneakiest pope ever.
What a conflict. On the one hand you have His Holiness’s strong statements in support of immigration and against climate change. On the other hand you have His Holiness’s meeting with Kim Davis, and standing against gay marriage, as well as Little Sister’s of the Poor, showing his solidarity with their stand against Obamacare.
Why didn't Francis tell that to Obama, in his face, in front of a worldwide audience; both at the White House and before Congress?
Francis meets with the murderous Castro brothers and Obama in public and publicly praises all three; yet he sneaks off to meet with persecuted Christians in secret. But like always, his secret "mercy meetings" are immediately made known, after the fact.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.