Posted on 12/22/2019 6:18:09 AM PST by Kaslin
I understand the point of the article, but it’s a bit of a reach to dislike Its a Wonderful Life because of abortion. It’s entertainment and good entertainment at that.
The writer doesn’t dislike the film, but rather finds the logical conclusion it leads to painful to contemplate. It’s like a parent of a dead soldier finding photos of the deceased painful to look at. They don’t dislike the photos, they just feel the pain.
“What if all those (aborted) children had been born?“
Black population % would be large, there would be no Republicans in office in any states with big cities, the wall would have been built long ago...just my guess.
Sometimes you just need to leave your worries and concerns at the door, and enjoy the movie.
You might seriously consider that it is MUCH more than simply ‘entertainment’.
It is hard to imagine a more important message, and lesson, than the one it delivers.
If anything it’s a pro life message.
The country is entirely changed because of abortion.
Who replaced those 60 million?
Mostly Mexicans. In 1970, ‘hispanics’ - nobody used that word then - were about 2% of the national population.
Now they are 60 million, or about 20% of the national population.
Note the number.
It’s about direct replacement - although the overall population grew by 100 million because of immigration in general, which includes Asians who had never existed in such numbers in the US.
So America aborted itself out of existence, only to be replaced by aliens, mostly from a country that hates the existence of Americans.
A beautiful thread thank you. You’re on a roll. :)
I am VERY pro life but it is also ABSURD to ignore that a LARGE number would have grown up in broken homes and gone on to commit horrific crimes.
That doesn’t mean they deserved to be MURDERED.
But let’s not talk ridiculous nonsense about the next Pasteur having been murdered without facing the flip side of the coin.
No it’s an absurd conclusion because like I said in another post, MANY would have grown up in broken homes and THE SAME PEOPLE HERE wailing and moaning would be calling for the death penalty for them.
THEY DESERVED A CHANCE! They didn’t deserve MURDER
But let’s cut the BS
Donna Reed was perfect in that movie.
And all those babies that would have been aborted not only would have gone on to do great things but would be voting Republican.
Buffalo Gals can’t you come out tonight.
Can’t you come out tonight.
Can’t you come out tonight.
Buffalo Gals can’t you come out tonight and dance by the light of the moon.
Actually, one argument for this movie is that George Bailey is a liberal. All Potter is doing is giving loans to people who earned them thru good credit and consistent employment. Bailey gives loans to people with questionable credit and ability to pay them back. Hence, Bailey is broke.
Potters way is If they don’t pay, they lose their house within the time allowed by law. Potter keeps Baileys money that his uncle misplaced, but otherwise is a law abiding business owner.
A good lesson in this movie for liberals is that George Bailey practices what he preaches and isn’t a hypocrite.
Agreed. Also, though I am pro-life, the same argument could be said for every possible person who could have come into life if we all were procreating every day to the best of our abilities.
A simple truth also is that many who were aborted, had they not been, would not have been followed on by children who were brought to term.
Too many hypotheticals to sling around!
how the hell do you know how they would vote? that’s crazy.
“a bit of a reach to dislike Its a Wonderful Life because of abortion.”
It’s more than a “Bit” of a reach! This is a passionate writer desperately searching for an interesting “parallel” to discuss his cause. Of course this film had not even a bit to do with abortion, it is about a good man and his self doubts during desperate times. Sometimes authors find themselves short of new material and end up delving into the absurd.
“ how the hell do you know how they would vote? that’s crazy.”
Each would know that if abortion were legal, they would have been aborted, and that fact would inspire then to be Pro-Life Republicans.
It’s a Wonderful Life is on my favorite films, but as a pro-life advocate who comes into contact with abortion-minded mothers all the time, it’s a bit painful to watch. Especially at the end when George Bailey gets to go back to his family after realizing how different things would have turned out had he never been born, and he gratefully clings onto his wife and children, it always makes me grieve for the millions of lives who have been lost to abortion and for the families who never experienced what life could have been like had they been born.
—
This a poor analogy verging on click-bait-y.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.