Skip to comments.Mars Mystery: What HAS Curiosity Discovered?
Posted on 11/20/2012 1:45:34 PM PST by Red Badger
Science isn't something that just happens overnight. It takes many measurements, oodles of analysis, re-testing and re-analysis before any groundbreaking announcement can be made.
So, on the surface of Mars, inside Gale Crater on a plain called Aeolis Palus, our tenacious six-wheeled Mars Science Laboratory (MSL) is doing cutting-edge laboratory work on an alien world and mission scientists are itching to announce a "historic" discovery.
"This data is gonna be one for the history books. It's looking really good," John Grotzinger, lead scientist of the MSL mission, said in an interview with NPR.
But what is he referring to and why all the secrecy?
For the past few weeks, rover Curiosity has been busily scooping dirt from a sandy ridge in a geologically interesting location called "Rocknest." Using a little scooper attached to its instrument-laden robotic arm, Curiosity has been carefully digging, shaking and dumping the fine soil grains into its Sample Analysis at Mars (SAM) and Chemistry and Mineralogy (CheMin) instruments.
Recently, NASA announced some results from SAM after analyzing samples of Mars air. Interestingly, clues as to Martian atmospheric history were uncovered. Also, mission scientists announced an apparent dearth of methane in the air -- a result that undoubtedly frustrated many hoping for the detection of the gas that may, ultimately, reveal the presence of sub-surface microbial life.
It appears that SAM has made yet another profound discovery... but mission scientists are keeping quiet for the time being.
One of the prime mission objectives is for Curiosity is to understand the past and current habitability for life on the Red Planet. Curiosity can not directly detect the presence of Mars life, but it has been kitted-out with miniature laboratories capable of not only establishing what materials soil samples contain, but also whether the Mars soil contains carbon-laden organic molecules.
Should Curiosity detect these organics, the mission will have confirmed the presence of the building blocks of life on the surface of Mars. This does not, however, preclude the genesis of life on Mars, it just means that some of the ingredients are there.
According to this NPR article, Grotzinger refers to the SAM data as being the source of the excitement. Indeed, one of the instrument's objectives is to address "carbon chemistry through a search for organic compounds, the chemical state of light elements other than carbon, and isotopic tracers of planetary change," according to the JPL mission site.
Might these data indicate the detection of organic chemistry? This would certainly be "historic" news. Also, this would back up the Viking landers' likely discovery of organics in the 1970s -- a result that could only be confirmed after Mars lander Phoenix made the groundbreaking 2008 discovery that the Martian surface is laced with perchorates.
Although the focus appears to be on organics, this is pure speculation for now. Science isn't about announcing the first result, no matter how profound, historic or earth-shattering it appears to be. As an example, the initial SAM results for Martian air analysis hinted at the presence of methane, only for that result to be proven false during follow-up tests -- air from Earth (which does contain methane) was trapped in the instrument and needed to be flushed out before pure Mars air could be properly analyzed.
NASA JPL mission scientists have, again, rightly decided that nothing needs to be announced until further work is done -- even though they've communicated their excitement for a big discovery. They are, after all, human.
So now we wait...
Image: The view from Curiosity after re-commencing its drive on sol 102 of the mission after camping out at Rocknest. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech
Looks like Afghanistan.
“Recently, NASA announced some results from SAM after analyzing samples of Mars air. Interestingly, clues as to Martian atmospheric history were uncovered. Also, mission scientists announced an apparent dearth of methane in the air — a result that undoubtedly frustrated many hoping for the detection of the gas that may, ultimately, reveal the presence of sub-surface microbial life.”
So all of the satellites orbiting Mars that detected methane were wrong???
Mars Needs Women!
I was thinking Detroit after they’ve leveled city blocks.
I’m definitely curious but I also recognize a need for a certain degree of hype.
A Twinkie left there by the Viking craft in the late 70s. Unwrapped. As fresh as the day it was baked.
But with a bite missing.
I hope this is not a Trump-style blockbuster announcement.
“We have reason to believe that there are large areas on Mars that the sun shines on. We are trying to verify this.”
mission scientists are keeping quiet for the time being
until Obama Admin makes up something
The article must’ve been written by a democrat. It has a lot of words, but doesn’t say jack!
Thank you, I'll be here all week, please make sure to tip your waiters and waitresses...try the veal.
Coprolite, and lots of it! Big piles. /s
Actually I thought it was pretty big news that they found that radiation levels on the ground are similar to what our low earth orbiting experience.
NASA is one of the very best government expenditures, and for many reasons.
I am relieved to see at least one mission picture without idiotic figures being photoshopped in. Gets old.
It's SAND! ROCKS AND SAND!
You spent billions of dollars to photograph ROCKS AND SAND!
They have to ask permission from Zippy so he can be ‘the one’ who really discovered it....unless it’s a bad thing.
To hell with Mars...Twinkies are moving to Mexico. Priorities...priorities.
That’s pretty good!
Why? This isn't www.nasa.com or Scientific Americans website.
Fun is good.
We have plenty of liberal women to send.
Oh, you’re no fun anymore.
Your intellect is sub par. we go to discover what is in our universe. If we did not explore and discover there would be no America to produce below average intellects
Sand. Rocks. Wow.
Still billion$ down a rathole.
Oh, yes. We await word of germs on Mars, it will be the biggest thing ever. As we deny that a growing baby in the womb is life.
Plus, he wrote “preclude” when he meant “conclude”, and “perchoate” when he meant “perchlorate” or “percholate”.
Definitely a Dem.
Those photos are SO cool!
Hey! Shrodinger’s cat. What do you know.
How’z he do that anyway?
So, if they found signs of life there (e.g. soil microbes, fossils etc.) what would our reaction be? Seriously. Would we be excited that life can exist elsewhere? Would it change the way any of us think? I don’t have an answer, but am curious how this would affect people. Thoughts?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.