Really? How so?
Posted on 02/09/2011 10:41:43 AM PST by BradtotheBone
“Life is good in Conservative Texas.”
We loved living in South Texas some years ago. Always wanted to retire there.
Really? How so?
In our house we observe it as an early confederate history month. Heck with April. The ugly wench can celebrate her heritage, I'll enjoy mine.
Only Coke Zero for me.
AND THAT is what Sheila is reacting to.
IF the roles had been reversed (excuse me, the 'races'), the 'black' community leaders would have immediately perceived it as RACIST and ran screaming to the talk shows.
HOWEVER, none of the 'white' community leaders (nor the 'whites' who viewed it) saw it as racist at all.
I saw it, I thought it was funny. It was a shock to see the girl get hit, which was the key to the commercial's success.
Nowhere in 'my' reaction was there even the least thought about race. The biggest reaction I had to the PEPSI commercials was that they kept portraying the guys as being BIG WUSSES.
What if the can had hit Sheila Jackson Lee in the head, instead of a white woman?
Can you imagine being SJL's boyfriend, and having her catch you EYEBALLING some Blonde?
YES, I think SJL is the one seeing racism in that commercial for personal reasons.
I totally disagree.
Attractive is attractive, no matter what 'color' the skin is. That babe was hot. Who wouldn't look? A blind man?
If it had been that tall dark haired beauty from the State Farm commercial, wouldn't the results have been the same?
Now, maybe what you stated is how SJL sees it. I would agree with that.
Considering we are supposed to be in a new era of civility (after the Tuscon shooting) I think Pepsi needs to apologize for encouraging violent behavior. And any network that railed against Palin and the ‘target’ map should take a stand and not only condemn this commercial but they should refuse to air it.
I liked the commercial. Made me laugh. I didn’t see anything racist to it at all.
Now..... how was that commercial supposed to ‘incline me’ to buy Pepsi? Would the woman have had better accuracy with Dr. Pepper?
PEPSI... misses it’s mark. Now go buy some?
I thought it was the funniest commercial of the Super Bowl, yet the least effective.
I just looked it up and watched it. No, there wasn’t anything racist about it. It wasn’t a slam at blacks and it didn’t portray whites as deserving of anything.
The female character shows remorse and states she is sorry as she runs off. She should have stayed to see if the women needed help, but that’s the only down side I would address.
The black woman who complained is an idiot.
I don’t see any basis whatsoever to say this is black on white racism either.
If any complaint were to be leveled, it would be women in general for being shown in that light, but anyone with a brain knew this portrayed one woman, clearly out of control.
It was supposed to be cute. Unlike you, I found it to be a bit tedious. If you were in the right mood and enjoyed it, that’s great. I have no problem with it. I can see how some people would find it funny.
Me having to look it up and view it with a critical eye didn’t exactly create a setting where I would view it casually and enjoy it for what it was.
I appreciate the comments.
It’s not real. All three participants are actors. The scene was scripted (by a young white writer). No one needed to be remorseful and no one needed aid.
Some points. First off, the notion of the jogger being far more attractive than the wife is an opinion and I’m not sure how such an opinion of how these two individuals compare in physical appearance relates to any real and serious underlying character and behavior patterns.
Next, it is far reaching to describe a man who sneaks and eats junk food behind his wife’s back as “skulking” and I am very much unaware of black men in any way being stereotyped as “henpecked”.
Lastly, can you give evidence to the idea of a tendency for blacks to flee scenes after accidentally hurting people?
I agree with your assessment.
Thanks LightningStriker2010.
Let’s just get right to the point and stop wasting time, shall we?
Do you think the black couple in the ad were, in general, portrayed negatively?
If so, do you think that this portrayal reflected negative stereotypes of black people?
(Both Spacewoman Lee and I have answered yes to these two questions. That is why I said I partially agreed with her.)
Final question (if you answer “yes” to the above two questions): Do you think that this stereotype is completely unfair? That is, do you believe that the negative stereotypical behavioral traits that you observed being depicted in the ad are, generally speaking, no more prevalent among black people than among Americans of any other ethnic group?
Of course...and that a flag is planed on Mars.
The only real stereotype portrayed was the aggressive and domineering nature of the wife (fleeing the scene after accidently hurting someone is bad, yet not any stereotype that I'm aware of).
I'm skeptical as to whether any stereotype is “fair” based on stereotypes typically being exaggerated. There is a comparatively higher rate of physical violence within black homes compared to the three major groups, so there is probably a higher rate of black wives assaulting their husbands.
But I would say that black husbands are less likely than other groups to take beatings from wives lying down (which is probably why there is a higher level of violence in black homes) and I have no knowledge of black men tending to sneak unhealthy food behind their wives’ backs. I would also say that black wives put less pressure on their husbands to eat healthy than other groups of women.
No. Since I can’t see me being SJ Lee’s boyfriend under any circumstance, the possibility of an altercation over a blonde is unthinkable as well.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.