Posted on 07/14/2009 9:00:10 PM PDT by Mount Athos
People who seek the services of auto mechanics want car repair, not "auto care." Similarly, most people who seek the services of medical doctors want body repair, not "health care."
We own our cars, are responsible for the cost of maintaining them, and decide what needs fixing based partly on balancing the seriousness of the problem against the expense of repairing it. Our health-care system rests on the principle that, although we own our bodies, the community or state ought to be responsible for paying the cost of repairing them. This is for the ostensibly noble purpose of redistributing the potentially ruinous expense of the medical care of unfortunate individuals.
But what is health care? The concept of reimbursable health-care service rests on the premise that the medical problem in need of servicing is the result of involuntary, unwanted happenings, not the result of voluntary, goal-directed behavior. Leukemia, lupus, prostate cancer, and many infectious diseases are unwanted happenings. Are we going to count obesity and smoking as the same kinds of diseases?
If we persevere in our quixotic quest for a fetishized medical equality we will sacrifice personal freedom as its price. We will become the voluntary slaves of a "compassionate" government that will provide the same low quality health care to everyone.
Henry David Thoreau famously remarked, "If I knew for a certainty that a man was coming to my house with the conscious design of doing me good, I should run for my life."
(Excerpt) Read more at online.wsj.com ...
bump
It’s not even universal health care, it’s universal health insurance. You can still be turned down for care, it’s just the government making the decision and charging you for it.
The ‘RATS like to say that free healthcare is “a right.” If that’s true, what the hell are the Commie ‘RATS forcing “the rich” to pay for it? I hate Commies.
A very LARGE percentage of the people who complain about “preexisting conditions” REFUSED to buy health insurance when they were still healthy!
By submitting to government health care we are surrendering our bodies to the government and we will forever be slaves.
I always liked the WSJ.They print facts not fiction.
Freedom’s Line In The Sand! Keep calling; keep the heat up. It’s a life and death issue.
Good article!
‘The ‘RATS like to say that free healthcare is “a right.” ‘
If it’s a “right” then why don’t we get the same health care program that Nancy Pelosi gets?
Indeed, we all shall.
But when it passes, what’s your plan B?
We need to stand up now because in a few days it will be too late...
It’s not even universal health care, it’s universal health insurance. You can still be turned down for care, it’s just the government making the decision and charging you for it.’
EXACTLY !! It is charging me for insurance- without my input- and making me pay toward the fools that use drugs and refuse to use condoms.
“if we persevere in our quixotic quest for a fetishized medical equality”
Brit Hume once said — they’d rather we all be equally poor than unequally wealthy.
BTTT
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.