Posted on 09/11/2008 10:29:40 AM PDT by j_hig
A real economic report card vs. conventional wisdom
Just last week, the Census Bureau released its annual study of household incomes, poverty and health insurance often called the nations economic report card. Its hard numbers seemed to confirm how many Americans feel. Sure, were prosperous; but prosperity is fraying.
Except for the rich, living standards are stagnant. Poverty is up; health insurance coverage is down. Naturally, both Barack Obama and John McCain seized upon the report to claim that their policies would restore progress.
Hold it.
Though echoed by policy wonks, pundits and politicians, the conventional wisdom is wrong or, at least, misleading.
Heres a more accurate assessment. For most Americans, living standards are increasing, albeit slowly, over any meaningful period. But rising health spending is eroding take-home pay, and immigrants are boosting both poverty and the lack of health insurance. Unless we control health spending and immigration, the economic report card will continue to disappoint.
Unfortunately, neither Obama nor McCain seriously addresses these problems.
Superficially, the conventional wisdom seems convincing. Census found that median household income in 2007 was $50,233. Though up 1.3 percent from 2006, that was still less than the peak of $50,641 in 1999. (The median is the midpoint; all figures are in inflation-adjusted 2007 dollars.) Meanwhile, the share of people below the governments poverty line about $21,000 for a family of four rose to 12.5 percent from 11.3 percent in 2000. Finally, the uninsured have increased in six of the past eight years. Theyre now about 15 percent of the population.
Case closed? Not exactly. Here are three reasons why (space precludes others).
First, comparisons are made to an artificially high benchmark the late 1990s tech bubble.
Remember the dot-com binge. Wages rose sharply; bonuses and cash incentives mushroomed. Unemployment and poverty dropped. In 2000, the jobless rate among white men 20 and over was 2.8 percent. But all these gains reflected a boom that, though pleasurable, was temporary and unsustainable. Stocks are now trading below their 2000 highs. Using these years as the base for comparison makes later years look bad.
Picking 1997 the last pre-boom year is more realistic. From 1997 to 2007, median household income rose $2,600, roughly 5 percent. Though hardly spectacular, thats not stagnation. The poverty rate in 2007 was slightly lower than in 1997.
Second, immigration distorts commonly cited statistics.
Low-skilled immigrants, concentrated among Hispanics, outnumber the high-skilled. They drag down median incomes and raise poverty and the uninsured. One way to filter out the effect on income is to examine groups with few immigrants or their American-born children. Consider non-Hispanic white families. From 1997 to 2007, their median incomes rose about $6,000 to $69,937, a gain of about 9 percent. For black families, the increase was also about 9 percent, though only to $40,222. Again, not stagnation.
Immigrations effects on poverty and health insurance coverage are greater. Since 1990, Hispanics numerically account for all the increase in the number of officially poor. Similarly, immigrants represented 55 percent of the increase of the uninsured from 1994 to 2006, says the Employee Benefit Research Institute. Many unskilled workers cant get well-paid jobs with insurance.
Third, the Census figures understate income gains by not counting fringe benefits.
Census counts only money income wages, salaries, dividends, interest payments. But compensation growth is increasingly channeled into fringes. From 2000 to 2007, only half (53 percent, to be exact) of the increase in average compensation came from wages and salaries, says economist Gary Burtless of the Brookings Institution. The rest went to health insurance (21 percent), pension contributions (19 percent) and payroll taxes (6 percent). Americans understandably feel theyre on a treadmill. They dont see fringe benefits in their paychecks, and small year-to-year cash gains barely register.
The real economic report card is both better and worse than the imagined. The big advances of the rich (which occurred mostly in the 1980s and 1990s and reversed slightly last year) havent prevented most Americans from achieving grudging gains. But a continuation of present trends would imperil future prosperity.
If health spending remains uncontrolled, Americans will see more of their compensation diverted from take-home pay into insurance that mainly benefits (as insurance should) a small proportion of very sick people.
Similarly, if the immigration of low-skilled workers continues unabated whether theyre legal or illegal the ranks of the poor will swell, as will the uninsured or the costs of providing government insurance.
Given the 2008 economy higher unemployment and inflation next years Census numbers will probably be worse than this years. But its the long-term threats that really matter. Obama and McCain dont confront them realistically because doing so would be unpopular and theres no strong public case for action. Thats the biggest cost of misreading the economic report card. n
Samuelsons column appears courtesy of The Washington Post Writers Group.
Why not just say the worst economy of the last thousand years so we can say it's worse than the Bubonic Plague years too?
Bookmark
Good information to combat the Dem’s talking points disseminated through the MSM.
Good information to combat the Dem’s talking points disseminated through the MSM.
Hiccup!
I think all our economic issues lie with trade and immigration. Even the playing field with trade (don’t make American workers compete with foreign slave-labor and artificially undervalued currencies) and immigration (don’t force communities to absorb the costs of millions of low-skilled illiterate workers), and then things will right themselves properly. Even a libertarian will admit that these are two of the federal government’s primary jobs.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.