Posted on 09/22/2004 7:15:52 PM PDT by vannrox
Scientists Find 75 Percent Of Red Snapper Sold In Stores Is Really Some Other Species
CHAPEL HILL ? While learning in a course how to extract, amplify and sequence the genetic material known as DNA, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill graduate students got a big surprise. So did their marine science professors.
In violation of federal law, more than 75 percent of fish tested and sold as tasty red snapper in stores in eight states were other species. How much of the mislabeling was unintentional or fraud is unknown, said Dr. Peter B. Marko, assistant professor of marine sciences at UNC?s College of Arts and Sciences.
"Red snapper is the most sought-after snapper species and has the highest prices, and many people, including me, believe it tastes best," Marko said. "Mislabeling to this extent not only defrauds consumers, but also risks adversely affecting estimates of stock size for this species if it influences the reporting of catch data used in fisheries management. The potential for this kind of bias in fisheries data depends on at what point in the commercial industry fish are mislabeled, which is something that we currently know little about."
A report on his group?s research appears in the July 15 issue of the journal Nature. Co-authors are his colleague Dr. Amy L. Moran, research assistant professor of marine sciences, and graduate students Sarah C. Lee, Amber M. Rice, Joel M. Gramling, Tara M. Fitzhenry, Justin S. McAlister and George R. Harper.
"The red snapper, or Lutjanus campechanus, is found in offshore waters around coral reefs and rocky outcroppings and is one of the most economically important fisheries in the Gulf of Mexico, with greater total landings?than any other snapper species," Marko and colleagues wrote. "In 1996, the Gulf of Mexico Fishery Management Council and the U.S. Department of Commerce declared that L. campechanus was grossly overfished and called for strict management measures to restore stocks to sustainable levels.
"Such restrictions create an economic incentive for seafood substitution, where less valuable species are mislabeled and sold under the names of more expensive ones. Substitutions among closely related fish are difficult to detect, because most distinguishing features are lost during processing."
The team conducted molecular analyses of 22 fish bought from nine vendors in Delaware, Florida, Illinois, Massachusetts, New York, North Carolina, South Carolina and Wisconsin. They found 17, or 77 percent, of the samples sold as red snapper were other species.
"Our work has a margin of error of 17 percent, meaning that between 60 percent and 94 percent of fish sold as red snapper in the United States are mislabeled," Marko said.
Among those sold as red snapper were lane snapper and vermilion snapper, two other species from the western Atlantic Ocean. Also surprising was that more than half the DNA sequences came either from fish from other regions of the world such as the western Pacific or from rare species about which little is known, he said.
"The remarkable extent of product mislabeling of red snapper threatens to distort the status of fish stocks in the eyes of consumers, contributing to a false impression that the supply of marine species is keeping up with demand," Marko said.
Freeper Recipe Corner: The only way to cook this fish is whole, head-on. Have your fishmonger gut and scale the fish, then stuff the cavity w/ fresh oregano, fine chopped tomatoes, red onion slices, and a crush clove of garlic.Toss a few pats of butter in there to, and some butter/lemon slices on top of the fish. Wrap the whole fish in tin foil so it's tightly sealed and will steam w/in the foil. For a 3 lb fish, bake it in a 350 degree oven for 35-40 minutes. Open foil. Enjoy!
i think your self-description "amazed" is too kind. walleye and great lakes perch are the best. mods.. close thread. (it's true.)
You never tasted my Walleye !!
You or any other FReeper come to Minnesota and I'll make the best Walleye you ever tasted !
Oh, I've had a variety of supposed freshwater delicacies...Yellow Perch, etc.
Not even remotely comparable to stuff like Black Sea Bass....
Fish is pretty much fish. I can tell the difference between tuna and cod, or swordfish and catfish, but you know, it's pretty much all fish. Some fresh lemon juice and a little salt and the only difference to me is a mild variation in texture.
Pickerel for me. Mmmmmm.
Carp.
This thread wouldn't have been complete without that exact UHF reference. Thanks!
Red snapper is indeed fine but not the best tasting snapper. The award goes to the queen snapper and to catch them you have to deep drop 1400 feet with wire line and an electric reel.
You obviously have never eaten properly spiced and fried bream or crappie. My wife (Katie_Colic) hates fish and our last batch was eaten cold the next day for BREAKFAST. I would have never believed it.
Walleye is my favorite.
And no, you can't deep fry wallpaper and pass it off as walleye.
Snapper don't even live around here.
Nonetheless, you can go to Safeway or any local market and buy snapper...Its friggin Rock Cod...
Clueless public...
I feel so cheated.
It is a function of sample size. Just like the +/- n% you see on polls. For all statistics, larger samples = smaller error; smaller samples = larger error. In this case they only have a sample size of 22 so the error bars are wider.
Thanks for the reminder. I need a refresher course in statistics.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.