GraphicaArtis/Corbis
Posted on 12/29/2015 5:30:12 PM PST by Coleus
¡Feliz Navidad! Joyeux Noël! Frohe Weihnachten! God Jul! Sretan Božić! Crăciun fericit! Priecīgus Ziemassvētkus!
How do you keep the Christ in Christmas if your language doesn't have a Christ in it to begin with?
The languages of the world have quite a variety of names for Christmas. That's not surprising, what with different languages having different words for things, but it turns out that our Christmas name stocking is stuffed with words that mean quite a few unrelated things. And many of them have nothing to do with Christ.
Christmas lands right at the same time as winter solstice festivals that were celebrated long before the coming of Christianity. That's likely an important reason Christmas is celebrated when it is: to co-opt the pagan festivals. (Jesus probably wasn't actually born on December 25. Scholars — including, in a 2012 book, Pope Benedict XVI — have raised many questions and made many suggestions about his actual birth date.) And Christmas isn't the only Christian celebration to co-opt pagan festivals: Hallowe'en and All Saints' Day take over from a fall festival, for instance, and Easter gets its English name — and those eggs and bunnies — from a pagan goddess, Eostre. Likewise, Christmas gets its trees and holly and mistletoe and even its gift-giving traditions from pre-Christian religious celebrations, and in many languages it gets its name from them too.
Take Yule, for instance (Old English spelling: Geol). Yule featured trees, logs, boars, carol-singing, and feasting at night. It appears in Scandinavian languages as Jul (or, in Iceland and the Faroe Islands, Jól) and was borrowed into Finnish as Joulu and Estonian as Jõulud — all now their words for Christmas. Yule was a festival of a holy night (or nights), and that's where German name for Christmas, Weihnachten, comes from: Middle High German wihen nahten, "holy night" (also converted by Czech into Vánoce). Oh, yes, it's holy for Christians too. It was easy enough to convert the festival to Christianity. Other nearby countries had winter festivals, too. In Latvian, Christmas is Ziemassvētki, which means (drumroll, please) "winter festival."
The Romans had a similar festival: the day of the birth of the unconquered sun. In Latin, that's dies natalis solis invicti. Just as the festival came to celebrate the birth not of the sun but of the son (of God), that word natalis, "of the birth," changed over time as Latin split into different languages. It became French Noël, Italian Natale, Spanish Navidad, and Portuguese Natal. Celtic languages also borrowed it: Gaelic Nollaig, Welsh Nadolig, and Breton Nedeleg.
Romanian also came from Latin, but in Romanian, Christmas is Crăciun, which is thought to come from Latin calatio, the name of a calling together of the people by priests — pre-Christian ones. Hungarian uses another version of the same word, Karácsony. In Lithuanian, Christmas is Kalėdos, which has an unclear origin but may come from the same source or a related one.
Birth shows up in other languages' names for Christmas, and it's not always easy to say whether the term started in reference to the birth of Jesus or whether it was carried over from a reference to a pagan birth (as of the sun god, for instance). In Polish it's Boże Narodzenie, "birth of God." Croatian Božić is a similar reference to God (or a god). Russian and Bulgarian are clear about whose birth it is: their name is Рождество Христово (Rozhdestvo Khristovo), meaning "birth of Christ." Albanian Krishtlindja means the same thing. So does Greek Χριστούγεννα (Khristougenna, which sounds to English speakers like "khristuyenna"). You'll notice that the Greek word starts with a letter that looks just like X. This is where Xmas comes from — English borrowed on an ancient scribal tradition of representing the Greek word Christos (Χριστός) with its first initial.
There are quite a lot of languages that have only needed a word for Christmas in fairly recent times. Some have used translations of "the birth of Jesus" or words to that effect — Mandarin Chinese 圣诞 shèng dà n means "birth of the sage." But many have gotten their word from whatever European language had the strongest influence on them at the time. Some use versions of Noel or Natal. Many use an adaptation of Christmas.
Ah, yes, Christmas. Our word comes from Old English Cristes mæsse, "the mass (liturgical celebration) of Christ." Dutch Kerstmiss comes from the same thing. Pretty much every other language that has a word with that origin got it from English or Dutch… and usually English.
In quite a lot of languages, though, "krismas" is not a possible sound combination. Some languages don't allow you to put the consonants together without vowels in between (so the Japanese version is Kurisumasu). Others don't use one or more of the sounds in the word. Thanks to Bing Crosby's song "Mele Kalikimaka," a well-known case of this is Hawai‘ian. Hawai‘ian doesn't have the sound "r" or the sound "s," and it doesn't allow two consonants to go together either. The closest it can come to Christmas is Kalikimaka, with l for r and k for s (k can also be said like "t" and possibly even "s" in some contexts, though no one told Bing that), plus some extra vowels. Yule would have been easier to work with…
We almost made it through the season without one of these stupid posts.
First, no one knows why Christmas is celebrated on 12/25. The conventional wisdom that it is to co-opt a pagan holiday is disputed by many scholars because Christians were not in the habit of using pagan holidays for outreach at the time we first hear of the date. Some argue that it is due to a belief that the Crucifixion was on the anniversary of His conception (which also requires some calculation errors). Others have even noted the similarity with the Feast of the Dedication on 25 Kislev. Others have argued that it is even possible that He was born on 12/25, because there was a field near Bethlehem where lambs destined for Temple sacrifice were kept, and they had to be watched all the time, all year round.
And as to the “Easter is named for a pagan goddess”, that is no more true than saying our 4th of July is really about Julius Caesar. “Easter” comes from the German name for the month when it is often celebrated, nothing more. It is only found in English and German - most languages use a term for resurrection, or a cognate of the Hebrew Pesah.
I love the internet, but man it sure can spread the BS.
/rant
Referring to the article, not to you :)
Well, slightly misleading, from a philosophical point of view, since they don't have an alphabet, but rather a syllabary, with a separate symbol for the syllables, ka, ki, ku, ke, ko, for example.
Also, it's pretty much impossible to say a consonant without a trailing vowel sound of some sort, like "duh", or "deh", so it's just a different way to organize things. I took Japanese at the local community college for two years in an evening class, and I recall a student asking the ( Japanese ) teacher, Why don't you say the "ooh" in "su" ? ... which they use for a trailing "s" in transliterations, as well as many Japanese words. The teacher insisted that they DO say it ... we just can't hear it!
But I wanted to mention a segment in the Huntley Brinkley report from the sixties, about the increasing popularity of Christmas in Japan. At the conclusion Brinkley intoned: ( and those who remember him can imagine his distinctive pacing )
"In America ... people complain that Christmas ... has lost its meaning.
Here ... It never had any."
Good night, Chet.
Good night, David.
Januar, Februar, Maerz, April, Mai, Juni, Juli August, September, Oktober, November, Dezember. The months in German. Which one sounds like Easter?
Noel and navidad (and the other Romance languages) come from Latin “natalis” (birth, referring to Christ’s birth). The Greek is roughly Christougenna, literally “Christ’s-birth”.
To dismiss countries that received Christianity from Spain/Portugal because their words for “Christmas” are variants of the Spanish/Portuguese words for Christmas is silly. To dismiss Christian holidays in the winter as automatically derivative of earlier winter festivals, and Christian holidays in the spring/fall as equally derivative because there were other holidays in those seasons is even more absurd. There is certainly some borrowing of traditions (and uncertainty on the actual date on which Jesus was born), but the central meaning of Christmas is unique to Christianity, which is why liberals hate sincere celebrations of Christ’s birth.
“First, no one knows why Christmas is celebrated on 12/25. The conventional wisdom that it is to co-opt a pagan holiday is disputed by many scholars because Christians were not in the habit of using pagan holidays for outreach at the time we first hear of the date.”
Well, actually, it was “co-opted” in the sense that it was chosen (at least in part) to KEEP Christians from getting sucked into pagan celebrations. Manfred Clauss mentions this in one of his books on Mithradaism with a quote from a Christian in late antiquity as evidence. See The Roman Cult of Mithras: The God and His Mysteries (page 66).
And the point of the article is?
(Old English: CrÄ«stesmæsse, meaning “Christ’s Mass”)
If it doesn’t reference Christ, it is not a word Christmas.
Old High German for April, but (AFAIK) only attested to by Bede, so even this association may be apocryphal.
>> First, no one knows why Christmas is celebrated on 12/25.
Because it’s 7 days before the New Year.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.