Posted on 09/07/2013 11:56:06 AM PDT by Rocky
Politicians pay for science, but scientists should not be politicians. Consensus is a political concept. Unwisely deployed, it can be damagingly anti-scientific. A reply to Naomi Oreskes (Nature, 4 September 2013).
The celebrated mathematician, astronomer and philosopher of science Abu Ali Ibn al-Haytham, or Alhazen, is justly celebrated as the founder of the scientific method. His image appears on Iraqi banknotes and on the postage stamps of half a dozen nations of the ummah wahida.
Al-Haytham, unlike Naomi Oreskes,[1] did not consider that consensus had any role in science. He wrote that the seeker after truth does not put his trust in any mere consensus, however venerable: instead, he submits what he has learned from it to reason and demonstration. Science is not a fashion statement, a political party or a belief system.
------------------- (snip) ------------------------
Science has become a monopsony. Only one paying customer the State calls the tune, and expects its suppliers to sing from the same hymn-sheet. Governments, by definition and temperament interventionist, are disinclined to pay for inconvenient truths. They want results justifying further intervention, so they buy consensus.
------------------- (snip) ------------------------
Accordingly, Oreskes statement that Political leaders who deny the human role in climate change should be compared with the hierarchy of the Catholic church, who dismissed Galileos arguments for heliocentrism for fear of their social implications is not only scientifically inappropriate but historically inapt: for no political leaders deny the human role in climate change, though some may legitimately doubt its magnitude or significance; and none impose any such opinion upon their citizens.
--------------------- (snip) ---------------
Insistence upon consensus has often bred the most brutal kind of intolerance.
(Excerpt) Read more at wattsupwiththat.com ...
You want consensus. Ask a group of 6 years old if Santa Claus exists.
The celebrated mathematician, astronomer and philosopher of science Abu Ali Ibn al-Haytham, or Alhazen, is justly celebrated as the founder of the scientific method. His image appears on Iraqi banknotes and on the postage stamps of half a dozen nations of the ummah wahida.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.