American Idol 2009--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^

[silent_jonny]

American Idol 2009

For Ladyinred

[sirchtruth]

The Brooke White fan would be moi. ;)

You know I love her too, but her performance and song were kind of weak. I expected her to be at the very least a little more polished.

[slugbug]

I knew there was someone on here besides me that loved Jason...I thought it was you! I was a Cook fan as well and voted for him and Jason. Apparently Jason has a song coming out called Love Uncompromised. It will be on iTunes for download on Tuesday...I imagine that’s what he’ll be singing on Idol.

[slugbug]

Hopefully Jamar will be back then! Maybe Michael Castro too...oh and to Jonny’s chagrin-David Osmond!

[Netizen]

Most of the recent articles don’t act like they will be picking from outside the top 36, which is as it should be. imo

[sirchtruth]

Back to actually discussing Idol, unlike what nuf wants to do: Betcha tatoo girl is a wildcard, along with Kai?

I am hoping Novel Tat Arm is a wilcard because I really like her presence, She stands out even without the tat!

Even though I don't even like Amy Winehouse, Megan is jumpin off on her singing style and it makes her interesting to listen to, and watch.

BTW, she's also quite easy on the eyes.

[kevkrom]

Last Tuesday's show "didn't quite gel. There were some audio issues. The lighting felt too light, too daytime," the Idol judge says. "We know what went wrong and what we're going to do to fix it."

Whatever they "fixed", it didn't work. It seemed like several of the contestants couldn't hear the monitors.

[retrokitten]

Leave Adam alone!!!!!

LOL!!

I don't care for his style, but he's an excellent performer. Randy was spot on when he said that Adam is very much what's happening right now.

[retrokitten]

Oh. Wow. LOLOLOL

For some reason I imagine she also has thimble collection and wears Quacker Factory sweaters.

[retrokitten]

I thought that they initially said it was only the top 36? Maybe they are realizing how boring this group is, too.

[sirchtruth]

By the way, I meant to add that I think Megan will get a wild cars spot.

I hope you're right because I personally think she has it! She really might not be the "best" singer, but there's something about her that just screams subtle quirky talent...it needs to have a chance bloom.

[sirchtruth]

Crazy. Then again, I bet they’ll still find time for some filler.

LOL! Yep that's a nuthouse scheduled segment if you ask me! They really screwed the pooch this year with this insane format. I'm not saying it's real bad, it just seems there's no conformity. Thanks for the link.

[sirchtruth]

For some reason I imagine she also has thimble collection and wears Quacker Factory sweaters.

ROTFLMAO! I don't know about the thimble collection, but...You nailed it on those sweaters!!!

[retrokitten]

LMAO!!

Maybe it’s not thimbles. Possibly spoons.

[Netizen]

I took it to mean that he was talking about this past week and that they haven’t fixed it yet.

[Netizen]

I think the article at 7676 is probably the correct one.

[sirchtruth]

I knew there was someone on here besides me that loved Jason...

Oh my daughter, the one that wrastled me on AI night one this year, stole my remote, and sent me to my room, loved mophead, ganja boy!

[Miss Didi]

Good news...can’t wait to see Dreads. ;)

[Miss Didi]

I have to agree; I was very disappointed. Like I said a few posts back—it’s like she holds herself back.

[Netizen]

LOL! Yep that's a nuthouse scheduled segment if you ask me! They really screwed the pooch this year with this insane format. I'm not saying it's real bad, it just seems there's no conformity. Thanks for the link.

I have a couple of questions.

If they are going to pick 8 or 9 out of the remaining 36, do those 8 or 9 know in advance so that they can prepare a new song or will they sing the same bad choice that no one liked before?

[sirchtruth]

Possibly spoons.

LOL! We both know it's got to be something metallic!