[Netizen]

LOL! Yep that's a nuthouse scheduled segment if you ask me! They really screwed the pooch this year with this insane format. I'm not saying it's real bad, it just seems there's no conformity. Thanks for the link.

I have a couple of questions.

If they are going to pick 8 or 9 out of the remaining 36, do those 8 or 9 know in advance so that they can prepare a new song or will they sing the same bad choice that no one liked before?

[AmusedBystander]

If they are going to pick 8 or 9 out of the remaining 36, do those 8 or 9 know in advance so that they can prepare a new song or will they sing the same bad choice that no one liked before?

It does seem odd as potentially the judges wouldn't know the results from the 3rd set of 12 until the day before the wild cards are scheduled to perform.

[sirchtruth]

If they are going to pick 8 or 9 out of the remaining 36, do those 8 or 9 know in advance so that they can prepare a new song or will they sing the same bad choice that no one liked before?

I don't know, but I would guess not. I think the judges should give them a chance to sing whatever they wanted. It will be interesting to find out if the format would be an On-The-Spot sing off!

[slugbug]

Surely they will get some advanced notice so they can pick a different song...Simon said last night that they might bring back some that were voted off the past two weeks that had pick the wrong songs...so I wouuld think they would get a chance to remedy that.