Virginia doctor, Siavash Sobhani, who was born in US loses his CITIZENSHIP after applying for new passport

https://www.dailymail.co.uk ^ | Nov 26, 2023 | By Laura Parnaby For Dailymail.Com

[Fido969]

If Harrison were to research U.S. statutory law to try to find the legal basis for his grandfather’s claim of U.S. citizenship, which rendered him eligible to run for and assume the office of POTUS, what would he find?

John Tyler was a citizen under the 1790 naturalization act, which, by the way, limited citizenship to whites.

[one guy in new jersey]

Tyler was a naturalized citizen?

Are you serious?

[RideForever]

you are an idiot, that is). So, you state that Islamic Muslims are not "subject to the jurisdiction of the United States". They'll be thrilled to hear that. They can now cite you as an authority.

No, you imbecile, I am saying you cannot remain a Muslim and become a citizen of the United States of America because Muslims advocate the overthrow of the United States of America.

Try laying off the hemp before noon, next time

[Fido969]

Tyler was a naturalized citizen?

I'm just telling you what law he was a citizen under. Read the law.

[Fido969]

No, you imbecile, I am saying you cannot remain a Muslim and become a citizen of the United States of America because Muslims advocate the overthrow of the United States of America.

You're the imbecile. If the individual is born in the US and subject to US laws, that individual is a citizen. The little newborn baby might "advocate the overthrow of the United States" in his little baby way, but the baby is subject to the laws and jurisdiction of the United States and is a citizen under the 14th Amendment.

[one guy in new jersey]

yikes

[StAnDeliver]

"Siavash Sobhani became stateless when he tried to renew his passport in June this year - with officials telling him that he never should have been granted American citizenship in 1960, according to the Washington Post."

So, firstly, his family was here at the Shah's bequest, de facto a guest of The Company. That's not exactly "diplomatic relations" with a neutral or foreign country. That is someone as a "military student" that was expected to serve US interests back in Iran.

Secondly, mistake-in-law can lay secondary to mistake-in-fact, where he was granted citizenship, a SSN, he's paid taxes, and made exponentially more of himself than non-citizen grifters with fake (or stolen) SSNs who have never paid taxes but have taken taxpayer money ... the solution is simple, he takes the citizenship test at the front of the line. Problem solved.

[RideForever]

If the individual is born in the US and subject to US laws, that individual is a citizen. ...
the baby is subject to the laws and jurisdiction of the United States and is a citizen under the 14th Amendment.

First off, whether you're born or visiting, you are subject to our laws while here, unless you are a diplomat with credentials. But it doesn't make them a citizen of the U.S.

Here's a link to Justia about this exception for sedition -

link

[Fido969]

A diplomat is NOT subject to US laws, hence “diplomatic immunity”.