Posted on 12/28/2011 5:32:30 AM PST by the scotsman
Thats a grossly simplistic reading of the Famine.
A Famine that killed hundreds of thousands of Protestants, contrary to myth which has only the Catholics deliberately starved. And Britain tried in several ways to alleviate the Famine, including buying grain from the US.
There were many Irishmen, and IRA operatives that fought for the whermacht
And the idea that Britain 1840’s feasted is ridiculous.
Most British people in 1845 were little better than the Irish. Most were poor and working class.
In the last few years in Great Britain, on Remembrance Day, English tv does a documentary on some long dead, young English soldier who was executed for cowardice during the First World War. These shows are unbearably moving. They find the descendents of these young soldiers who try and tell their history through photos and family lore. Many of these young men were victims of shell shock and/or gassing.
Personally, I think the men who deserted the Irish Army and joined up to fight Hitler were and are heroes.
There were many Irishmen, and IRA operatives that fought for the whermacht
True.
I think the point is that given what they did, and why they deserted (they didnt desert out of cowardice, in fact the complete opposite!), and that whilst other Irishmen supported and even helped the Nazis, they fought them, that over 70 years after the war started, that Ireland should celebrate these men and their heroism and bravery and moral choice. And treat them accordingly.
Its ironic imo that whilst Ireland was essentially founded by terrorists and had for many years men in govt who were guilty of some appalling crimes and were hateful men towards the British and even simply Protestants, that these brave men who deliberately deserted because they wanted to fight evil are pariahs.
They did.
As did some Welsh Nationalists.
Did you read the article? These frail old men who were at the D-Day landings, imprisoned by the Japanese and helped to liberate Bergen Belson?
Of course, I tend to think of the IRA (especially in those days) as a raggle-taggle militia. Some of my ancestors were at the Post Office on Easter Day.
True.
Thankfully they were massively outnumbered by those who fought the Wermacht, SS, Luftwaffe and Kreigsmarine....
Even many who hated the British stopped well short of supporting the odious regime of Hitler.
Amen sister.
You either need a course in reading comprehension or a course of psychotherapy.
Sorry, do you mean the lighting of fires on the roofs?
My best pal (a victim of the Blitz) always says they simply lighted lamps during the blackouts. Since he’s always pretty snide about my people, I tend to disbelieve him, lol.
Having said that, the Irish who left to fight Hitler should be honored. Even if they deserted to do it.
Amen, brother!
They werent, thats a myth.
The early IRA were terrorists, and did target civilians. In 1916, 1918-22, and people completely forget the bombings on mainland Britain by the IRA just before WW2. The idea that the early IRA were somehow morally different to the IRA of 1969-today is frankly a nonsense.
The modern IRA has simply been better armed and more efficient.
I guess about ninety percent of the people on this forum are “messed up” and “sick”, huh?
We do worse to deserters in the U.S. military.
I was just reading about the supporters of Hitler from Ireland and the middle east during WWII. I got your statement reversed. So sorry. I read the entire article and I agree.
They lit fires in the surrounding mountains to guide the Luftwaffe into Belfast.
http://markhumphrys.com/sfira.tyranny.html#ww2
http://blog.z-word.com/2009/01/gaza-jewish-legislator-in-ireland-compared-to-goebbels/
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.