Skip to comments.
If I tell you that I'll have to kill you: Red Hat fights the DMCA [Digital Millenium Copyright Act]
The Register USA ^
| 10-16-2002
| John Lettice
Posted on 10/16/2002 3:03:29 AM PDT by JameRetief
click here to read article
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-36 next last
To: Ernest_at_the_Beach; rdb3
FYI Ping.
To: JameRetief
I am of the opinion that hackers generally do us a valuable service. If you can extend the "virus" metaphor a little, the multitude of virus' help innoculate us. When China decides to destroy the US Internet infastructure, oops, those hackers have prevented this. Better to get a bunch of small ailments that create persistent antibodies than to be unchallanged but vulnerable to a killer attack.
To: John Robinson; B Knotts; stainlessbanner; TechJunkYard; ShadowAce; Knitebane; AppyPappy; jae471; ...
The Penguin Ping.
Wanna be Penguified? Just holla!
![](http://johngalt.crosswinds.net/anim/tuxanim048.gif)
Got root?
4
posted on
10/16/2002 6:46:57 AM PDT
by
rdb3
To: rdb3
Is that graphic suppose to black out like that, or is it corrupted?
![](http://johngalt.crosswinds.net/anim/tuxanim048.gif)
I love those penguin things. The superhero one is my favorite.
5
posted on
10/16/2002 7:51:45 AM PDT
by
Jalapeno
To: rdb3
Not sure I understand. Anyway of explaining this is some form of layman's terms?
6
posted on
10/16/2002 8:14:23 AM PDT
by
billbears
To: billbears
If you find a security hole in somebody elses software, you cannot publish your findings, That would violate the Digital Millenium Copyright Act, and exposing you to possible prosecution.
7
posted on
10/16/2002 8:29:20 AM PDT
by
demlosers
To: billbears
If people cannot get the word out about flaws it would remain a problem until the proprietary software company fixes it, which may never happen. Since the word did not go out, its not a well known problem. The OEM may forget about the problem or could drag their feet to fix the flawed software, because there is less pressure to do so. The outlaws in the hacking community(not saying all are outlaws) would most likely hear of the problem and exploit it, which in the end, leaves the user(you and me) vulnerable to hacks.
8
posted on
10/16/2002 9:13:38 AM PDT
by
demlosers
To: demlosers
Can you imagine if this law applied to telling others about for example a car safety defect you discovered? You would be forbidden to tell anyone aobut it because it would violate the Vehicle Millenium Copyright Act, exposing you to possible prosecution.
9
posted on
10/16/2002 9:40:41 AM PDT
by
afz400
To: demlosers
If you find a security hole in somebody elses software, you cannot publish your findings, That would violate the Digital Millenium Copyright Act, and exposing you to possible prosecution. Wonder whose idea this was? Wonder whose software has more security holes than swiss cheese? Wonder who knows they have security holes but does nothing about them until someone screams.
10
posted on
10/16/2002 9:42:00 AM PDT
by
gore3000
To: gore3000
RedHat does seem to be treading very carefully here, in contrast to a certain software company which ignores laws and court orders.
XMMS, as shipped with RH 8.0, will not play MP3s. This is due to some concerns about patents. (The Ogg Vorbis folks have an interesting response to the MP3 royalty stuff.)
The RPM which restores MP3 functionality is available here, but be aware that this web site is in Norway. Importing this software may also violate the DMCA, since it allows the circumvention of the royalty.
Comment #12 Removed by Moderator
To: billbears
Not sure I understand. Anyway of explaining this is some form of layman's terms?In this particular case, RedHat has posted some fixes for "potential security holes" on its web site, but the explanation of why these are security holes cannot be provided to US eyes lest they violate the DMCA.
So the details have been provided to a web site in the UK, which has copyrighted them, and has instituted a mechanism (a click-thru license agreement) that controls access to the information. As shown in the article above, the license agreement specifically states that if you are in the USA, you are not allowed in.
Under the DMCA, it is illegal for those of us in the USA to represent that we are NOT in the USA, for the purpose of reading the details, since that would circumvent a technological measure used to control access to a copyrighted work.
Now, do you see how stupid this is?
To: TechJunkYard
Reckon how a Linux user is supposed to know whether he needs to apply the specified patch?
If it ain't broke, don't fix it. And don't fix it if you don't know what it is you're supposedly fixing.
14
posted on
10/16/2002 11:09:43 AM PDT
by
gitmo
To: TechJunkYard; demlosers
I understand now, thanks very much. Still doesn't make much sense except maybe to protect a company that isn't making a very good product in the first place
To: billbears
except maybe to protect a company that isn't making a very good product in the first place Bingo.
To: demlosers
If you find a security hole in somebody elses software, you cannot publish your findings, That would violate the Digital Millenium Copyright Act, and exposing you to possible prosecution.
Do you have a list of people who have been successfully prosecuted under DMCA?
17
posted on
10/16/2002 11:52:19 AM PDT
by
Bush2000
To: TechJunkYard
RedHat does seem to be treading very carefully here, in contrast to a certain software company which ignores laws and court orders.
Is Oracle really that bad? ;-p
18
posted on
10/16/2002 11:53:03 AM PDT
by
Bush2000
To: JameRetief
Bravo for Red Hat. I have been using their OS since v4.0, and have been very happy with it.
19
posted on
10/16/2002 12:10:35 PM PDT
by
Utilizer
To: Bush2000
Is Oracle really that bad? ;-pGood one! ;-)
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-36 next last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson