Posted on 08/24/2023 4:34:15 PM PDT by FarCenter
“Until we do.”
LOL. Okay, if we somehow invent either a time machine or develop immortality, then you might turn out to be right. Neither of those things has happened yet though.
“Forensic science is the application of criminal and civil laws.”
Well, forensics is often used to denote the use of science in ways that relate to the criminal or civil justice system, but it is not “application of criminal and civil laws”.
However, that’s not the sense of the word that I am using anyway. The word “forensic” has a more general definition, which involves scientific analysis of evidence in an attempt to reconstruct a past event. That’s the way I am using it, to distinguish it from actual experimental science that can deals with events that are ongoing, or recurring, and happen on timescales that humans are capable of observing and replicating.
“Well, forensics is often used to denote the use of science in ways that relate to the criminal or civil justice system, but it is not ‘application of criminal and civil laws’.”
It is the application of many disciplines (especially the sciences) to criminal and civil laws. There are forensic archeologists, forensic accountants, forensic engineers, etc. I dealt with them quite often in my career (I am retired, now).
“The word “forensic” has a more general definition, which involves scientific analysis of evidence in an attempt to reconstruct a past event.”
No, it doesn’t have a more general definition. The word “forensic” derives from the root word “forum,” which denotes a public place for judicial and public business; basically, a gathering for a public purpose, the most common of which was — and is — for a court proceeding or for the purpose of conducting government business, or debate.
Your “general definition” of “recreating a past event” is called anthropology, and its integral specialized discipline, archeology. That’s why we have the disciplines of forensic archeology and forensic anthropology (which my wife studied in college), which deal with evidence used in law.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.