Posted on 08/28/2013 5:42:49 PM PDT by kevcol
LOL! this is so true!
Again. She completed the purchase, it was her property, she accepted the bag and walked some distance knowing it was not properly bagged and did nothing to resolve it.
Your what if scenario is not analogous.
I wouldn’t put a whole lot of faith in those bags either.
I have had one of those bags that was only a few weeks old fail on me.
The threading on the handle was so weak that the handle just ripped off the bag. Fortunately my wife was carrying the bag at her side and the contents hit the ground and not her feet.
Tort law has a term “proximate cause” which means the harm must be reasonably foreseeable for the harm caused to be a negligent act. Here, the death is too far removed from the bag breaking to be such a wrongful act. Case dismissed, costs charged to the plaintiff.
Where does the shopper’s responsibility start and the vendor’s stop, for freak accidents? The deep pockets phenomenon has bent America’s sense all wacky for it punishes the conscientious rather than rewarding them. I reluctantly grant that since she was on the premises still, the store will have to eat something, if not all of it.
I bought boxes of 12-ga shotgun shells at a local sporting-goods store. The clerk put it all in one plastic bag. When I picked up the bag from the counter, the bag broke and the shells flew out if the boxes all over the floor. Luckily, none hit my toe or I could have sued! I asked for a double bag, scooped them up and was on my way. The look on other customers faces was priceless, as I bought a large quantity that day.
It is the baggers job to bag it properly, not hers.
If I pay someone to balance my tires I expect them to be balanced, if on the way home I feel a sudden resonance at 70 MPH and a wheel falls off is it my fault for not double checking the tire technicians work?
a torn bag with stuff cascading out is a pain.”
Particularly if you didn’t plan on serving the entire carton of eggs scrambled.
Who knows how the lottery will turn out. As “reasonably foreseeable” makes so much sense the feelgood dogooders will not want to hew to it.
You didn’t even check for dents? :-)
” Now we have to use reusable bags because they are the “most” environmentally friendly. Except reusable bags are not clean”
__________________________________________________
Yes, and you have to carry them with you to the store.
ALL of my plastic bags are reused, either to store things here in the house or for bagging tubes of ice that I sell to the neighbors, fishermen, and juice vendors.
So you admit you accepted the shoddy product/work!
If the product had been damaged, would you have asked for it to be replaced or would you just eat it?
It was no fault of your own was it?
This woman died.
And if one of those cans bipped some one below in the head, who is responsible?
First, they aren’t baggers, they are checkers. And, once she picked up the bag (going down the road at 70 MPH), and felt how heavy it was, she should have had it double bagged or put into more than one bag.
The person driving at 70 MPH and feels the wheel unbalanced has an obligation to stop and pull over to the side of the road. If they continue down the road at 70 MPH with the wheel shaking and lose a wheel and cause a wreck, they are responsible. She continued down the road and an accident happened.
Yes I have. I was carrying it in to work and the glued seam just ripped open. I looked at the folded seam and there was just the thinnest line of glue to hold the box closed.
I now always carry those boxes supporting it from the bottom and never use the carry handle. I also never use those boxes in the fridge the way they are intended to be used either. Having that box fail in the fridge when I open the door does not appeal to me.
What are “they” going to do about a broken toe?
Clean it, disinfect the wound and tape it up? I can do that.
Now if it was a compound fracture with broken toe bone splinters piercing my skin, even I would probably seek professional medical attention.
My local walk-in clinic will charge me about $150.00 for that level of treatment.
The ER would charge about $1500.00.
You seem to be very intent on blaming someone else for the woman's toe injury.
I have to wonder why?
Is that how you make a living?
It happened on their property and was caused by someone not doing their job.
Good catch.
You are one tough monkey!!
It’s a scam.
They are killing themselves for money.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.