I still get spun up when people compare the US to other countries. Our numbers are low not because our education is terrible - though yes there are definitely areas that need improvement. However, we have an albatross around our neck that we put there. I’ll explain:
In the US 100% of students are measured to determine high school graduation and other metrics.
In Japan after middle school students test to determine not only which high school they will attend, but if they will attend. Those who do not test well apprentice out or go to a trade school. These students are not included in the graduation or other metrics for Japan in the calculatons. The same is true for most other asian countries. Therefore, their numbers look better than ours when in fact they aren’t.
I can’t speak to european countries, but would not be suprised if something similar were occurring.
I do not advocate changing our measure, but I do advocate ensuring that everyone is measured on the same level to ensure proper reporting and actions. Do I believe that a large number of students are not receiving proper education - yes. Do I blame the schools 100% nope.
In my home nothing happens till the homework is done and explained. They don’t have homework from school - that’s ok we have some review to do. Do I think this happens in every house - nope....and that is where the real problem is. Sure I’m tired when I get home at 6-7 but we eat supper as a family and then sit till the work is reviewed (and it better be done by the time I get home). As with most things - once the routine is started early it self sustains and instead of a long 2 hours it becomes a 15-20 minute checkup.
It isn’t my responsibility to educate other people’s children - but I pay my property taxes and don’t complain. It isn’t the teacher’s responsibility to educate my childeren it is theirs to instruct and provide a plan - and I have complained about insufficient plans and workload.
sigh it’s too easy to give up, ya gotta fight for the important stuff.