Posted on 05/23/2010 5:25:34 PM PDT by Ernest_at_the_Beach
I think I’ll throw a grenade in this thread and leave. At one time, the Constitution defined a Negro as 3/5 of a human being.
Insofar as this particular issue goes, I find myself siding with liberals rather than libertarians.
However, as you pointed out, liberals are not content to legislate equal access or opportunity. As with Title VII, they use it like the camel's nose under the tent to impose their view of equal results and justice which, as it turns out, are seldom equal and never just.
Japan, just to cite my previous example, tend to be both a more equitable and a more just society because the liberal view is much more restrained than it is here.
At the beginning of this debate, the northern states didn't want the slaves counted in the census at all because they did not have the rights no responsibilities of citizens. The southern states took the rather hypocritically view that they should be fully counted because they were, in fact, homo sapiens. The 3/5th compromise was a tacit recognition that they did contribute to the national economy and, thus, the tax coffers with their labours and, as such, deserved some recognition.
Many of the slaveholders at the time rationalized their actions by claiming that they had saved the lives of the slaves by making them more valuable alive than dead, which too often was the result in the tribal wars prior to the slave trade.
This is why your early anti-slavery societies combined freedom with captivity with resettlement in Africa and considered the Liberian Colony which they founded a model of success. The freed American slaves, once settled, promptly went out and captured locals to work as slaves on their plantations.
It was viewed as appropriate justice since the then fairly recent ancestors of the American freed slaves had been sold into slavery by those same West Africans.
Thank you for the correction. I mean that. It reminds me of the "old days" on FR when nearly every post was fact-checked by other members who didn't hesitate to correct. In fact, not so long ago I would have heard from at least 5 people on that one.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.