Posted on 07/15/2008 4:56:18 PM PDT by Nachum
Are you KIDDING me? I have never heard of such a thing. In some places like when I lived in Switzerland, they would not allow you to post the mezuzah with a nail. So we used that blue sticky tacky (gum-like) substance that held it up there but could come completely and cleanly off when we moved out.
This sounds truly like discrimination since Jews MUST post mezuzot. I mean, does it take up any more space than a doorbell or knocker??
It may be a case based on WHERE the common area begins. Perhaps the common area begins at the wall of the hallway. A tiny mezuzah within the doorway (on the inner jamb) might be still part of the individual’s condo. I think there is a case for it, and it does seem like discrimination.
Why does this condo board fuss over it? Don’t you think there are many condo buildings that are filled with Jews where certainly no one minds the mezuzah on the door? Who would would to die on the hill of making sure no Jews could live in a certain building? Jews talk... LOL.
Well, dunno, I s’pose it prevents people from hanging inverted pentagrams from their lintels too, eh? I guess everybody is protected from any sort of Islamic symbols also, eh? Why in fact we’re all protected from ANY religious iconagraphy whatsoever by this ruling.
Evangelism is already prohibited in the same vein as soliciting is probibited. Physical violence against the latter would be just as frowned upon as the former. I don’t attempt to evangelize anybody after the second admonition against it; they’re on their own.
Association documents outline what is owned. In many condominium associations the “owner” only owns the interior of their unit through the first two coats of paint. They do not own into the walls - even inside their own unit. It is common area. The door to the unit and the walls in the hallway are also common area and not owned by the individual.
What is individually owned and what is common area is explicitly spelled out in the association documents and known to all at time of purchase.
Why does the association board fuss over it? Because people push the envelope and it sets a precedent. If I want to hang something ridiculous, e.g., a porno picture on my door I can point to the mezuzah as a precedent. Then people will post pictures of Elvis or Jesus on their doors. You get the picture.
Some people are not cut out for condominium living. They want to expand their space and decorate the hallway outside their unit.
So in Jewish retirement condo areas, is there a bylaw allowing a small mezuzah, so no one has that problem?
Every condominium has its own association documents and its own rules and regulations.
I lived in a condominium once that had very strict association documents and rules about what is common area. However - they had no problem with mezuzahs. When I moved in there was one at my front door. I left it there. Every bit of extra protection you can get is helpful. ;)
BTW, they were very picky about what could be left outside your door, e.g., baby carriage, wet umbrella. The rule was: NOTHING.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.