Posted on 04/03/2008 3:34:56 AM PDT by BGHater
Thank you for the reply.
“If there was an appreciable difference in epigenetic sexual differences then reciprocal crosses between populations would be different”
Is this opinion the result of research? The first part of your answer suggests not. I’ll admit that I would expect there to be differences.
Oregon seems very dry to me but I live in Pennsylvania which is much much wetter than even the coast of Oregon. The caves they investigated are definitely in a dryer part of Oregon, a little over 100 miles from the Nevada/California border. One article (from the U of O) does call them “desert” caves.
Why would you expect a difference? Every human populations exhibit the same sexual behaviors.
If there was a human population that exhibited, lets say, total promiscuity, then the males would have larger testicles, and would have changed the epigenetic expression to demand maternal resources even if it was detrimental to the overall health of the female; the female would respond by changing the epigenetic pattern that she passes on to blunt this effect.
When men from the usual human population had a child with the female from the ‘promiscuous’ tribe the children would be freakishly small. If a male from the ‘promiscuous’ tribe had a child with a female from the usual human population the resulting child would be a giant.
There has been no observed difference in reciprocal crosses, humans from all populations are very genetically similar, share a very recent common ancestor, and exhibit identical sexual characteristics. Your expectations fly in the face of absolutely every piece of data collected on the subject so far. But go ahead and speculate, the data isn't in yet; but there is little reason to expect any sort of difference along these lines.
After reading at the link you provided it would seem you're right. Problem for me is, there is so much junk that gets passed off as science, it's difficult to separate the wheat from the chaff. There are so many sacred cows within the scientific community, I approach most all it with a good deal of skepticism. These people have been pretty conservative in reaching any conclusions; not always the case.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.