Posted on 09/19/2006 6:45:40 AM PDT by montyspython
Ako Bog da indeed.
Perhaps we should "unify" the threads... (pun definately intended)
Dear Brilliant,
Certainly, most Protestants agree with the Catholic Church more than they disagree.
However, the differences between the Catholic Church and Protestantism, generally, are too great to overcome to achieve intercommunion or any sort of organic unity. Heck, the differences between the various flavors of Protestantism prevent the same thing between all Protestants.
sitetest
But they are predominantly issues of tradition and custom. The fundamental test for salvation is pretty much the same whether you're Catholic or Protestant.
Dear DManA,
"ELCA Lutherans and the Roman church came within a hairs breadth of coming into communion together a few years ago. As I understand it the last hurtle was on the point of the authority of the Pope."
I think that is an overly optimistic read of what actually happened. What happened is that theologians of the Catholic Church and of Lutheran groups agreed to a joint statement on justification. The joint statement more or less came to the conclusion that the differences between Catholic and Lutheran theology were principally differences of semantics and emphasis. Nonetheless, not even this document purported to fully resolve all differences.
When this document arrived at the Vatican, the pope accepted the existence of the document, but the Catholic Church added its own statement pointing out where the Catholic theologians had been perhaps a little too eager to finesse all differences. The statement applauded the progress in understanding between Catholics and Lutherans. It noted that the joint commission had significantly narrowed differences between Catholic and Lutheran theology on justification, but that some critical differences remained.
I suspect there are still major, likely unresolvable issues concerning sacraments, the Eucharist, Mary, the communion of saints, and ecclesiology, and that's even without throwing the papacy into the mix.
sitetest
Dear Brilliant,
"But they are predominantly issues of tradition and custom."
That may be the view of some Protestants, but not of the Catholic Church.
The Catholic Church does not believe that crucial differences only relate to tradition (lower case "t") and custom. The Church believes many of the differences come down to different interpretations of Scriptures, and down to Sacred Tradition from the Apostolic era (which are part of Divine Revelation, along with Sacred Scripture).
Although many Protestants may not consider our Sacred Tradition to be part of Divine Revelation, the point is, we do. So do the Orthodox.
"The fundamental test for salvation is pretty much the same whether you're Catholic or Protestant."
I'm not sure you could get all Protestants to agree with that, no less the Catholic Church.
sitetest
Tradition is so entrenched in certain circles that I believe many seem to confuse one for the other or don't differentiate the two at all. There are those who seem to follow tradition as more of a doctrine than really understanding the word.
The dichotomy of institutionalized religion can sometimes hamstring itself in providing a solid ground for teaching the word.
ping
What is the key to salvation, though? The theologians in the Catholic Church (as well as the Pope) will tell you that the key to salvation is to acknowledge Christ as God, and accept Him as your savior.
And that's the same test for most Protestant denominations as well.
All the rest is dressing.
Dear Brilliant,
"The theologians in the Catholic Church (as well as the Pope) will tell you that the key to salvation is to acknowledge Christ as God, and accept Him as your savior."
Actually, the Catholic Church would say that one will go to Heaven if one dies in a state of grace.
sitetest
And what does that mean?
Dear Brilliant,
To die in a state of grace is to die with no unforgiven mortal sins.
sitetest
And, of course, to have received the sacrament of Baptism, which gives grace to the soul that was dead due to Original Sin.
But how do sins get forgiven?
I'll grant you that the packaging of the concept is different, and that is what separates the Catholic Church from Protestantism. On the other hand, it really boils down to pretty much the same thing if you follow the rabbit all the way to the end of the trail.
Who wants their religion boiled down?
Is faith about the absolute minimum amount of information that we must confess in order to be spared damnation?
Or did God want us to know more?
SD
True, but it is at the dividing line that you define what a Christian is.
Dear Brilliant,
"On the other hand, it really boils down to pretty much the same thing if you follow the rabbit all the way to the end of the trail."
I guess I'm a bit reluctant to follow the rabbit, if you will. It's time-consuming, it's been done, and I'm not necessarily the best interlocutor with which to attempt it.
The question of justification was precisely that to which DManA referred. The supreme authority of the Catholic Church did not conclude that it all "...boil[ed] down to pretty much the same thing if you follow the rabbit all the way to the end of the trail."
I'm not really willing, inexpert that I am, to try to retrace all the steps taken by the Catholic theologians and the Lutheran theologians, and then retrace the steps of Pope John Paul II to get to this conclusion, especially in the hope that I might come to a different conclusion.
However, it would be wrong to think that there could be communion with the Catholic Church if there were complete agreement on the issue of justification. There are more essentials to Catholic Faith than just justification.
sitetest
OK. Well, I'll agree with you that they are different. My point is that they are not as different as one might think, though obviously both Catholics and Protestants think otherwise.
Dear Brilliant,
"OK. Well, I'll agree with you that they are different."
Thanks.
"My point is that they are not as different as one might think, though obviously both Catholics and Protestants think otherwise."
Actually, what you said originally was:
"The primary difference is that the Catholic Church is steeped in tradition."
As I explained, this is false. The primary differenceS [capitalization intentional] are that we interpret Scripture differently from Protestants, in some fundamentally different ways, and that we understand Sacred Tradition to be a part of Divine Revelation, and thus, we understand the history of the Church in a significantly different way.
sitetest
A shepherd must tend his flock and, at times, fight off the wolves.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.