Amateur Hour?

National Review OL ^ | August 18, 2006 | Bryan Cunningham

[yoe]

Her sophomoric and ACLU tied findings will not stand. Another activist judge exposed.... .......

[MNJohnnie]

And he was being genteel here. Much to easy of this goof ball of a Judge

[L98Fiero]

"Another activist judge exposed..."

The epitome of an activist judge. Ruled purely on "feeelings".

[BW2221]

Even many who agree with her ruling admit her process was flawed.

[Thombo2]

"We can sympathize with her motives..."Speak for yourself.From what i've read,i believe the program is in fact legal and the majority of Americans support the program.This is nothing more than a leftist judge trying to impose her will(and her parties will)on the American public and negatively affect our ability to defend ourselves from terrorists.No sympathy for this judge.

[BW2221]

The ACLU is known for "judge shopping," finding a sympathetic judge that is like to find in its favor. I am sure this was the case.

[Lonesome in Massachussets]

So what if the facts, law and precedent are against her? She has the New York Times on her side.

[Dilbert56]

Handled properly, this is an election year issue. Activist judges are getting a bad reputation and this ruling will be another highlight.

[saganite]

Link to her bio.

http://www.daahp.wayne.edu/biographiesDisplay.asp?id=64

[July 4th]

So, how to explain her first-year failing-grade opinion?

She's exceedingly lazy, and let her partisan hack summer law clerks write it.

[Vn_survivor_67-68]

"—most importantly, the entire line of Supreme Court and other decisions, most famously including Curtiss-Wright Export, cited many times since Youngstown, making clear the president’s constitutional primacy in foreign-affairs/foreign-intelligence collection, upon which neither Congress nor the courts may intrude."

[Neoliberalnot]

A couple million bucks in a foreign bank account can easily buy a RAT judge. People are always willing to sell to the enemy for the right price--check with Clintoon and Chicoms on this one.

[the invisib1e hand]

America haters everywhere must be rejoicing. And communicating.

[brushcop]

People who "mean well" often send others into slavery.

[traderrob6]

Related.....

http://exposingtheleft.blogspot.com/2006/08/nsa-wiretapping-decision.html

[null and void]

Fixed your typo:

She's exceedingly lazy, and let her partisan hack summer law clerks the ALCU lawyers write it.

[mkjessup]

[yoe]

"....making clear the president’s constitutional primacy in foreign-affairs/foreign-intelligence collection, upon which neither Congress nor the courts may intrude."

Great catch! Passing it on to all.

[Recovering Hermit]

She may regret her decisions while her head is being sawed off by some islamic nutbag.

[TalBlack]

"...the only plausible explanation is that she wanted the result she wanted and was willing to ignore and misread vast portions of constitutional law to get there,..."

Golly, that sounds a lot like Affirmative Action doesn't it?