Posted on 03/14/2005 8:55:54 AM PST by NormsRevenge
Uggh. Not another article on this crap.
They're never very clear that the author is only claiming a "dirty bomb" test, which is just slapping some radioactive stuff around a regular high explosive. Not a very effective weapon, and it is to a true nuclear bomb what a BB Gun is to an M-16.
I dunno, I read Richard Rhodes' The Making of The Atom Bomb and he said nothing like this.
If this is true the Nazis had the beginnings of an implosion device, and they tried an open air test near Berlin?
Or had a serious criticality accident, also near Berlin?
A crude nuclear device, meaning, when they tested it, the bomd replied the chief researcher was a pooftah, questioned his legitimate heritage, and things of that sort (only, in gutteral German).
BS
How 'bout Physicists?
Didn't think of a dirty bomb. Rhodes mentioned that and stated that both sides considered using synthetic radioisotopes but both concluded that the concept was not practical.
Actually the Germans developed the theory that the US exploited. It's just that by the time of WW2, the NAZI's had chased the researchers to the US.
I do not buy this. The isotopes would still be there and easily detected ever after all these years, even it were a "dirty bomb" or a true nuke.
Rhodes was right. This crude device was a dirty bomb, and would not initiate a fission reaction. Calling it a 'nuclear device' is ignorant or deceitful.
They understood how to make and fire a handgun, what they lacked was steel and gunpowder and lead and brass.
"German physicians" designed a nuclear bomb?
Good thing the silly Krauts didn't have their physicists working on it or the world would've been in deep trouble.
hogwash!
Sounds like typical second finishing Euro "Us too, us too." BS.
If they'd a had it, they'd a used it.
We were closer to losing WWII war than anyone even knows.
What they lagged on was the engineering expertise to put the theories into practice. The US spent billions to develop this expertise in a short period. The Nazis simply did not have the resources to spend on this development. What little they put aside for new weapons development was spent on jet fighters and the V1/V2 missiles.
They were not even close to developing an A bomb. They had no equipment for seperating U235 on an industrial scale, no reactors for plutonium production, no research facilities for determining the critical masses necessary (interesting stories from Los Alamos on "tickling the tiger" from a physics prof I had), etc.
See # 15
See #9, an excellent point- if it was a "dirty bomb" or fizzled attempt at fission, the debris would be detectable today.
A Japanese dirt bomb attack would have guaranteed total destruction of the Japanese homeland.
Well, I discount the reports that anything went off at all. That would make perfect sense.
The idea that this went undetected for sixty years is ludicrous.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.