Posted on 02/11/2005 1:46:57 AM PST by Elle Bee
Well, "maybe" is the answer. We no longer have a communist enabler in the WH, we have a globalist. It depends on whether a free Cuba fits into the 'big picture'.
I know, that's cynical. Sorry.
So what you are saying - the same level of poverty, the same level of dictatorship, the same level of fear, the same persecution, the same possibility of torture - but you would allow immigrants from one, but not the other?
Yeah - that's real logical. When I said politics being different - I was referring to the title of their politics - a ruthless dictator is a ruthless dictator - regardless of the labels "we" put on them.
I fail to see how being from Cuba is any worse than being from some of the other dictatorial countries in Central America.
One of the distinctions you fail to recognize is geographic distance. Another is political clout. Can't do anything about the first, and little about the second.
It's simple to argue that a dictatorship is a dictatorship is a dictatorship. Finding a false equivalency makes a fine excuse for inaction.
You saw the same argument when the U.S. invaded Iraq: "why Iraq and not N. Korea?"
The fact of the matter is that Cuba is not Guatemala. Wishing the two are the same gets you nowhere.
Huh? I did? Thanks for letting me know - because I didn't realize I saw that same argument in that case.
No - I totally understand the Iraq invasion and not yet taking action against North Korea. We just are not ready for action in Korea - our armed forces would need to be greatly bolstered both in numbers and in equipment. Iraq was a "doable" situation. The WOT will have to be fought one step at a time as the opportunity and ability dictates.
Now back to the immigration deal - I have not ignored the geographical reality of Cuba being a VERY close neighbor. I just don't think it's all that relevant, other than making it physically easier for folks to get here.
The truth of the matter is - our continued cold-war stance on Cuba has done what? Castro is living to a ripe old age, still in power, and still oppressing the citizens.
And I do not WISH for Guatemala to be the same as Cuba. The truth of the matter is that many of the so-called "3rd world" countries live under a harsh dictatorship. In fact, Cuba represents something actually a step above the other countries we look at as "3rd world". I just don't agree with this political immigration version of affirmative action. Cubans are no more needy than many others even in our hemisphere (and may actually be better off than some).
I'll bet the public servant who stamped it is still on the job
.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.