Posted on 12/26/2004 1:20:04 PM PST by 4.1O dana super trac pak
just ignore jveritas.
He posted a vanity thread on this subject of illegal immigration, and then had the gall to put "Bush Bashers" in the title.
You talk about "jobs that Americans will not do."
Q: How is it that these jobs are done by Americans in states with low illegal immigration rates?
Q. You talk about allowing the free market to work.
-Why not apply this principle to the jobs "Americans will not do," and allow the free market to bid up wages for American workers?
Q. How do you propose to pay for the education, and health care for the families of foreign workers who will do "the jobs Americans will not do"?
____________________________________________
I will answer all three.
Q1: In states with low immigration rates, market conditions are such that illegals don't go there because they are not needed. They go to regions where their labor is needed and rewarded.
Q2: Restricting labor availability will drive up some labor rates which increases inflation, interest rates and reduces the standard of living for the American Consumer. The interest rate rise would probably kill the stock market and the housing market too.
Q3: Guest workers should not be allowed to bring their dependents. They should be workers. As far as health care goes, most of our health care budget is going to treat the chronic illnesses of the elderly, the consequences of drug, alcohol, and tobacco abuse, and paying for useless tests to avoid malpractice suits. The acute care for illegals is a very small part of the health care problem.
jveritas vanity thread:
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-bloggers/1303552/posts
I smell a red herring. If AQ was totally wiped out, you would argue some other reason for stopping the guest worker program.
I think you would do everyone a favor by not assuming we are so stupid to not see a red herring.
This is about socialism, not illegal immigration. Any poor person in america gets free medicaid. It is something I can't do either because I'm not poor.
There is nothing wrong with driving a junky car. I've driven a junky car for most of my life because I'm cheap and now I'm a lot better off and have a lot more economic freedom than those who constantly buy a new car every 3 years.
Since the number of illegals is estimated at 10 million, and the number of voters is 120 million and 1 illegal can at most displace 1 citizen worker, then your conclusion would be correct.
Sometimes doing nothing is better than doing the wrong thing. The big push behind all this is the Mexican government is demanding this. Question their motives --- but it's not for us --- it's for them.
You make an excellent point. But is the solution to shut down the business or to remove the externality. If you want to remove the externality, you need to remove welfare benefits from illegals and remove them from citizens too so that citizens will go to work instead of chilling on the front porch.
You've got one of the most corrupt governments in the world behind this push for this "guest" worker program --- we don't need that government trampling on our sovereignty and making our laws.
This is an interesting article --- it doesn't say why a guest worker plan is needed in the first place --- but it makes some interesting points about why the Mexican government should not be involved in our domestic laws in the first place.
Guest-worker plan is needed, but not under pressure
When it comes to the United States working out some kind of immigration/guest-worker program with Mexico, there's a certain sense of urgency on each side to see this accomplished.
But Mexico might be showing a bit too much urgency.
But President Vicente Fox and other officials need to exercise some care when trying to pressure and influence U.S. officials and public sentiment about an immigration program.
The Dallas Morning News recently reported that Mexican government officials are planning to lobby in the United States at several levels on behalf of the undocumented workers.
A little attention is needed here because this is a domestic issue, and the Mexican government must exercise caution.
For one thing, what would happen if the United States tried to intervene in what Mexico considered an internal matter? As has happened before, Mexico would cry "sovereignty infringement."
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1308667/posts
None of this is coming about as a result of the American people wanting it --- what happened to government of the people, by the people, for the people --- now it's government for the Mexican government.
Vicente Fox and the corrupt Mexican government would not be pushing so hard for this if they believed it would reduce border crossings --- or if they believed a single guest worker would ever be returning to Mexico. The Mexican government sees this as a big solution to their problems --- they plan to have many many more of their citizens over here as a result of this. Vicente Fox has never hid that he intends for much more. Just like when it was first announced --- Vicente Fox starts high-fiving his fellow elites shouting "we're going for more! we're going for more!".
One final note.
I have a friend from Sweden, and they have the same problem as we have. For them it is poor arab immigrants. They can't speak Swedish, and they will never assimilate.
A country that has more than one predominant language will eventually "Balkanize." This is where we are headed if we don't get a handle on immigration:
"Swedes Reach Muslim Breaking Point"
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1290944/posts
G'nite
No foreign government should be or should be attempting to dictate our domestic laws.
Not a good foreign government --- but definitely not a crap foreign government like Mexico which cannot fix it's own laws to make it's own wealthy nation more liveable for it's majority --- the fact that the Mexican government is the major push behind this means it's bad. We need our laws to be determined by what is good for the American people --- and Mexico should have no say on that.
I certainly wouldn't put extortion like that past Vicente Fox or any of his cohorts. He seems to believe he has a lot of say in our laws --- he believes he can cram this through and to hell with what the American people want. Watch the Mexican government come in and try to throw out Proposition 200 in Arizona --- and I excpect they will try to do just that.
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-bloggers/1303552/posts
Thanks for the link.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.