Posted on 07/27/2004 12:17:17 PM PDT by Borges
I showed this list to the head of the English department at my univ. and one of the first things he said was 'where the heck's Boethius?' :)
They put I Ching before the Bible????
Useless list.
Darn right!
If the Exodus is dated to the 14th century BC as it is by most historians and theologians and the first five books of the Bible were first written down by Moses as is thought, wouldn't that mean the I Ching predates it?
I have something of a soft spot for books that weren't even translated into English until very late - The Thousand Nights And One Night for example. Sir Richard Burton's wife actually burnt his original translations for obscenity... She was cursed as a thoughtless Victorian prude until somebody figured out just how obscene they really were...
When you're translated by everyone from King Alfred to Chaucer you've held some influence I would say.
My suggestions:
Third rate = Concept, story, or information is presented so poorly, that you can't finish the book.
Second rate = Something's amiss, but you can finish the book, either for entertainment value, or some information.
#7 The Avesta is a collection of earlier writings going back to the seventeen Gatas (sacred songs) composed by Zoraster. The writings are in an ancient language called the Old Avestan. These writings should be in the #1 spot, as they were modified into the latter written Old Testament.
I've read an awful lot of books and to this day Atlas Shrugged is still, without a doubt, the most influential one I've read. The beginning was a struggle, the meat of it was like breathing life itself into my soul and reaching the end was half an awakening and half a wake wishing it wasn't ending. And no, I'm not usually melodramatic about this kind of thing. It was that good.
ping
This nearly four thousand year old work is studied today at West Point and the Naval War College. My dear wife, who sells real estate, is reading it for the fourth time and still taking notes. She also bought another five copies for coworkers and our teenager.
I would submit for consideration that the absence of Sun Tsu's _Art of War_ makes this list highly suspect.
Mary Mother of God! My new glasses aren't ready yet.
ping
and
I would complete agree that the Art of War belongs.
Lik I said I would take out everything on the list post 1900, and put in books like Art of War and John Locke's Second Treatise on Government.
In his entry on Clausewitz he suggests that this update on Sun Tzu's work has had the greater influence.
Ive actually read only 14 in their entirety - and reread them.
The Old Testament
Homer The Iliad. The Odyssey
History of the Peloponnesian War
Herodotus History
Plato The Republic
Virgil The Aeneid
The New Testament
Plutarch Lives
Cornelius Tacitus Annals
The Divine Comedy
The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire
The Origin of Species
War and Peace
Nineteen Eighty-Four
Ive read parts of a couple dozen others on the list - but wading through The Upanishads, Augustine of Hippo Confessions, or Thomas Aquinas Summa Theologiae is a bit more than I can handle. Maybe when I reach the point where I have absolutely nothing else to do
Skinner, Chomsky, and Kuhn do seem to be waning in influence though.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.