Skip to comments.
ARTILLERY: Rules of Engagement Protect Iraqi Mortars
StrategyPage.com ^
| November 26, 2003
Posted on 11/26/2003 4:14:38 AM PST by Cannoneer No. 4
click here to read article
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-64 next last
Whose learning curve is faster?
Spectre could break Iraqi mortarmen of bad habits.
To: Darksheare
Incoming
2
posted on
11/26/2003 4:15:25 AM PST
by
Cannoneer No. 4
(Old soldiers never die. They just go to the commissary parking lot and regroup.)
To: 1stFreedom; Redleg Duke; SAMWolf; American in Israel
High Angle Hell Ping
3
posted on
11/26/2003 4:18:21 AM PST
by
Cannoneer No. 4
(Old soldiers never die. They just go to the commissary parking lot and regroup.)
To: I got the rope
ping
4
posted on
11/26/2003 4:26:58 AM PST
by
Cannoneer No. 4
(Old soldiers never die. They just go to the commissary parking lot and regroup.)
To: Cannoneer No. 4
The only missing aspect to this is the ineffectiveness of their tactics for putting steel on target. Firing one or two mortars from a hasty position, sight guessing the aim of the first round and with a planned withdrawal within minutes of the first shell fired practically guarantees missing the target.
Any effort to improve their chances of hitting their target makes them vulnerable to being caught.
The conclusion then is that they are satisfied with the media attention they get by just dropping a few close to their target and playing the stats that once in a great while they might get lucky.
To: Old Sarge
ping
6
posted on
11/26/2003 4:35:52 AM PST
by
Cannoneer No. 4
(Old soldiers never die. They just go to the commissary parking lot and regroup.)
To: 300winmag
ping
7
posted on
11/26/2003 4:36:51 AM PST
by
Cannoneer No. 4
(Old soldiers never die. They just go to the commissary parking lot and regroup.)
To: Prodigal Son
ping
8
posted on
11/26/2003 4:40:57 AM PST
by
Cannoneer No. 4
(Old soldiers never die. They just go to the commissary parking lot and regroup.)
To: optimistically_conservative
And the solution is simple...you allow a tube to be set up in your back yard...we level your backyard...next landlord to offer space available for a mortar? Step right up!
Oh, to see that C-47 gunship back and blast again! Provides a very nice lesson in payback!
9
posted on
11/26/2003 4:43:33 AM PST
by
NMFXSTC
To: optimistically_conservative
It's a lot like shooting a hotel with an RPG. Makes noise, busts glass, scares journos, gets coverage, adds to the anxiety level of folks in the States who think it is worse than it is. 4GW. They aren't all that good at killing us, but they are real good at making us feel bad about what few successes they have.
Even a blind hog finds an acorn every once in a while. Too many Americans are too quick to blame the leadership when we take casualties. I think the enemy has something to do with it.
10
posted on
11/26/2003 4:48:14 AM PST
by
Cannoneer No. 4
(Old soldiers never die. They just go to the commissary parking lot and regroup.)
To: Cannoneer No. 4
To complete the scenario, the bad guys set up an ambush along the known routes to that site. Coalition troops race to the site hoping to catch a perp but run into an ambush instead. This scenario plays itself out daily in Iraq and was also used heavily in Lebannon a few years ago.
11
posted on
11/26/2003 4:55:21 AM PST
by
Ranger
To: Cannoneer No. 4
Sounds to me like they limit what they do or they die... Doesn't sound like they are becoming more effective, just adaptive.
So in this war of attrition, my guess is that they are losing.
We are not hearing the whole story right now, and surprisingly, the part we may not be hearing is how quickly the other side is being attrited.
To: Cannoneer No. 4
Don't return fire, follow them home and then take out the whole nest using whatever is 10 times larger than needed.
To: optimistically_conservative; neverdem
Firing one or two mortars from a hasty position, sight guessing the aim of the first round and with a planned withdrawal within minutes of the first shell fired practically guarantees missing the target. Kinda sorta. It depends on whether or not the have a skilled FDC (fire direction controller) type, accurate maps, etc.
Shooting by eyeball, they'd be lucky to hit a football stadium sized target. using a map, sight, aiming stakes (or the equivalent) they should be able to shrink that considerably
Let's ask neverdem, a weasely little FDCer if there ever was one...*grin*
(fancy pants FDC types with their Gamma Goats and dry working conditions grumle grumble)
To: Cannoneer No. 4
Title is misleading. It should read Rules of Engagement protect innocent civilians.
I don't know if you've ever seen the results of an artillery strike, even a small one with 60mm mortars, but I'm here to tell you even if our targeting was 100% accurate dropping shells in a populated area would be devastating.
15
posted on
11/26/2003 5:47:02 AM PST
by
Ispy4u
To: Cannoneer No. 4
Sounds kinda like the VC.
16
posted on
11/26/2003 5:50:30 AM PST
by
OldEagle
(Haven't been wrong since 1947.)
To: Ispy4u
OTOH if the civilians in the area are smart they will hightail it out of the area when the guerillas start firing.
But the title is still slanted against the ROE, the only option to having no rules hinder our troops is to have no rules at all.
17
posted on
11/26/2003 6:05:06 AM PST
by
Ispy4u
To: NMFXSTC
And the solution is simple...you allow a tube to be set up in your back yard...we level your backyard...next landlord to offer space available for a mortar? Step right up! First of all, many times the Iraqi homeowner has no say in the matter. Someone sets up in their back yard at 0200 and he's asleep. Second, this is the tactic that the Israelis have taken with Palestinian Homocide Bombers - they bulldoze the bombers' family home. Not great for P.R.
The solution is to try to get the co-operation of the Iraqi people to report these things, and to hunt down the scum ringleaders.
As satisfying as it sounds, cratering back yards of possibly innocent civilians is not the answer, and would only fuel anti-American sentiment among the population. Let's not allow emotion cloud our judgement.
18
posted on
11/26/2003 6:21:58 AM PST
by
Yo-Yo
To: Yo-Yo
We need snipers scattered around the area surrounding the base. They won't get them every time, but when they do, any survivors will tell their friends, and they may think twice about firing mortar rounds at our bases.
19
posted on
11/26/2003 7:09:47 AM PST
by
Hoosier-Daddy
(It's a fight to the death with Democrats.)
To: Cannoneer No. 4
You cannot fire your artillery into a populated area. And this is where the Iraqis usually fire their mortar from ...This sounds a lot like North Vietnam. We were not allowed to bomb populated areas ... so where do you think the anti-aircraft guns were placed?
20
posted on
11/26/2003 7:10:47 AM PST
by
JoeGar
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-64 next last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson