American Idol 2006--Live Thread (Part III)

Fox ^ | 5-8-06

[retrokitten]

Cingular must have sensed my frustration cause as soon as I posted I hadn't got a confirmation I got reply that my votes were being counted.

I don't do the resend because I thought that might be the case. I added "Elliot" and "Taylor" to my address book, so I could do it quicker. :-)

[BamaDi]

yahoooooo....just got through too and heard his delightful voice thanking me....and i'm sure it was a personal thank you to me! I love the Soul Man! Can't wait for his first CD....

[TonyWpi]

"She has sucked for a long time IMHO."

That's why she's lasted so long.

[OldFriend]

Silly, it's the Elvis effect. Remember how the TV stations would only show Elvis from the shoulders up!!!

[Echo Talon]

Taylor did good.
I think Tonight was Taylor, Chris, Eliott, fat Kat

[silent_jonny]

I could like Simon this evening...

I think Simon hit the bullseye tonight on every song--except for his comments on Taylor's first performance.

[BamaDi]

well heck, I'm going out and buying some really tight ones now....makes me feel better to know I look like MM....hey, one can dream!!!

[Echo Talon]

That's why she's lasted so long.

Her looks... Which I think are nasty

[RobFromGa]

DialIdol Score

Margin Of Error

Actual Rank

1-2

Taylor Hicks

69.375

2.914

-

1-4

Elliott Yamin

66.833

3.033

-

2-4

Katharine McPhee

62.333

3.232

-

2-4

Chris Daughtry

62.333

3.232

-

[LA Woman3]

Sorry for the double post...both links lead to tonight's performances.

[TonyWpi]

I still think this years "final four" is the best so far.

I'd be "ok" with any of them as winners, but I'm rooting for Taylor and Elliott.

[silent_jonny]

Seacrest to Taylor: "Did you ask her (Pricilla) on a date?"

And Taylor got kind of awkward there, didn't he :)

[andyssister]

Thanks for the link.

Listening again, Chris was better than I thought and Katherine just didn't bring it tonight. IMO

[BamaDi]

you may think he's a dork with no star quality but down here in south alabama he has a huge following - not from AI but from his frequent performances in places in Mobile and Baldwin counties. One person's dork is another's American Idol!

[misterrob]

Carrie Underwood went triple plat, won country music and gospel awards....

riiiiiiiggggghhhht

[OldFriend]

Well, never having been in a single Karoake bar I wouldn't know......but I do know mean and snarky dear.

[TonyWpi]

You missed the joke...LOL

[BamaDi]

I've gotten through ONCE since the polls opened!!!! Yeah, I'll probably sleep well as well as sweat buckets!!!

[Echo Talon]

thats just wrong! Chris's first song ruled! Both of Kat's songs sucked!

[silent_jonny]

Sadly and painfully, that list could go on and on and on...

And Mary Tyler Moore is at the top :o