An objective, numeric value for the number of threads of one type vs. another type can be found, and a simple count of said threads shows that as of this point, there are more anti-Catholic threads posted by Protestants than vice versa. There is no circular reasoning to be had, because it ends with a concrete value that cannot be redefined. If you want to claim you lack the ability to count integers, by all means be my guest.
I can see that you people got together through FReepmail or something and decided to start throwing around the NTS fallacy, because it's suddenly popping up from multiple members of your troop. I suggest you return to the council wigwam and discuss when it is actually applicable.