[metmom]

If Catholics go to far, this is one thing you never hear Fundamentalists say.

Really???

Because I've heard plenty of non-Catholics talk about that.

The difference is, that by saying *blessed* we don't presume it to mean a whole passel of things that are not supported by the context.

It was a great honor to be the one chosen to carry the Messiah. I've heard it was the dream of every Jewish girl to fulfill that role.

So yes, it was a blessing. But it does not make her into a sinless, immaculately conceived, never died, perpetual virgin.

[BeadCounter]

Really??

Where does the Bible say it is only supported by the Text?

Nice try, only after so much criticism and one points out the verses of Luke, “all generations call me blessed” do we hear Fundamentalists then say “oh, we call her blessed.”

[mlizzy]

So yes, it was a blessing. But it does not make her into a sinless, immaculately conceived, never died, perpetual virgin.

From Fulton J. Sheen:

Can religion do without motherhood? It certainly does not do without fatherhood, for one of the most accurate descriptions of God is that of the Giver and Provider of good things. But since motherhood is as necessary as fatherhood in the natural order—perhaps even more so—shall the devoted religious heart be without a woman to love?

[boatbums]

So yes, it was a blessing. But it does not make her into a sinless, immaculately conceived, never died, perpetual virgin....who can and will answer unlimited prayers to her, who was taken bodily into heaven, who will get you out of Purgatory, convince Jesus to do what you ask her to and if you don't believe everything that's declared, you will go to hell. I think that IS too far.