Posted on 12/16/2014 10:22:20 AM PST by jazusamo
Last week, the Obama administration announced new curbs on racial profiling by federal law enforcement. Before deciding whether this is good or bad policy, we might try to develop a description/definition of racial profiling or any other kind of profiling.
A good definition of profiling in general is the use of an easily observed physical characteristic as a guess for some other, difficult-to-observe characteristic. The reason people profile is that information is costly and they seek methods to economize on information costs. One way to do that is through profiling.
Imagine a chief of police in a city where there has been a rash of automobile hubcap thefts and he's trying to capture the culprits. Should he have his officers stake out and investigate residents of senior citizen homes? What about spending resources investigating men and women 40 or older? I would imagine that he would have greater success in capturing the culprits by focusing most of his resources on younger people — and particularly on young men. Doing so would more likely lead to the capture of the culprits because hubcap theft is a young man's game. My question to you is whether you'd bring charges against the police chief because he used age and sex profiling — and didn't investigate seniors and middle-aged adults.
Some years ago, a Washington, D.C., taxicab commissioner, who is black, issued a safety advisory urging D.C.'s 6,800 predominantly black cabbies to refuse to pick up "dangerous looking" passengers. Cabbies in D.C. and other cities often bypass black males for fear of robbery or of being taken to an unsafe neighborhood. We seriously misunderstand the motives of a taxi driver who racially profiles and passes up a black customer if we use racism as the sole explanation for his behavior.
(Excerpt) Read more at creators.com ...
A one-legged midget wearing a glowing yellow hajib robs a bank and kills a cop. Should the police profile or just stop and search everyone. This is more LIB insanity. Someone remove them from this society!@
Just because only a very tiny pct. of black male deaths are caused by unfavorable (for the black male) interactions with police officers and six or seven thousand black males are shot and killed by other black males annually is not reason enough to discard the crime of noticing.
Have they published a definition of “what is profiling?”
They must have defined what things cannot be done by LEOs because doing those things would be “profiling.”
Let’s see the specifics.
Only liberals think profiling is irrational, counterproductive or racist.
For the rest of us, it comes down to plain good old fashioned, common sense.
Good column. Some profiling is nothing more than a description of the suspect. Sometimes it gets offensive, as in the taxicab issue. But understanding the real problem and placing anger and fixes where they belong is the only way out. I’m not saying cab drivers should not pick up black customers in areas where black crime is high. I think they should. But it does not help to label them racist when they are just trying to live to see tomorrow. They didn’t cause the problem.
We had a policy issued that falls in line with the fed guidelines.
Not saying it is right.
Yep, common sense is what it’s about.
One idiot can be attached to this current insanity on doing away with racial profiling-—Eric-the-Red Holder.
A one-legged midget wearing a glowing yellow hajib robs a bank and kills a cop. Should the police profile or just stop and search everyone. This is more LIB insanity. Someone remove them from this society!@
= = = = = = = = = = =
I used to ‘weewee’ them off by saying if you are in Logging Country during Paul Bunyon Days and the main suspect was a ‘big guy’ riding a ‘Blue Ox’, if you are bowlegged and wearing a checkered shirt, expect someone to ‘talk’ to you.
Well said.
Answer: No.
Comment: To ban profiling would be impossible as a moments reflection would establish. What is really sought by those seeking to ban profiling is black immunity for crimes.
Well, there goes the Criminal Minds TV show. /s
:-) It slays me the way everyone in the group takes their turn at profiling and Presto, they solve the case.
ABANDON ALL SELF-PRESERVATION INSTINCTS*, YE WHO ENTER HERE.
(*common sense)
Not until the left uses it to stop, search, and arrest every Bible, gun toting conservative.
One CANNOT do his job as a cop, and not profile racially. It is impossible!
Hope not.
An outright ban would make it very hard to construct sewer lines and roads.
In a police report if the race of the suspect is omitted then they are black. All other races are always explicitly mentioned.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.