Posted on 10/22/2020 9:21:00 PM PDT by ebb tide
Homosexuals have a right to be a part of the family. Theyre children of God and have a right to a family. Nobody should be thrown out or be made miserable because of it. What we have to create is a civil union law. That way they are legally covered. I stood up for that.
Thats a quote from Pope Francis. Pope Francisthe Bishop of Rome, the Vicar of Christ, the Supreme Pontiff of the Catholic Church. And not only has he come out in support of civil unions for same-sex couples: he has also confirmed old rumors that he did so in his native Argentina as early as 2010. For at least a decade, Francis has quietly but actively dissented from Church teaching on human sexuality.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Lest there be any doubt, in 2003 the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faiththen led by Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger, who was appointed by John Paul IIdeclared:
The Church teaches that respect for homosexual persons cannot lead in any way to approval of homosexual behavior or to legal recognition of homosexual unions . Legal recognition of homosexual unions or placing them on the same level as marriage would mean not only the approval of deviant behavior, with the consequence of making it a model in present-day society, but would also obscure basic values which belong to the common inheritance of humanity. The Church cannot fail to defend these values, for the good of men and women and for the good of society itself.
That is indeed the perennial teaching of the Catholic Church. And the Pope is now on the record dissenting from that teaching, publicly and unambiguously.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Up to this point, Ive tried very hard to give Francis the benefit of the doubt. No longer. The Pope has made it abundantly clear that his mind is not with the mind of the Church. He doesnt believe in the sacred deposit of the Magisterium. He doesnt feel bound to the Churchs traditions.
Some readers will accept that implicitly. Others will not. So, lets be very clear: One of the first principles of Catholic social teaching is that immoral acts must not be given legal sanction. Thats why the Church plainly teaches that abortion (CCC, 2273) and pornography (CCC, 2354) should be prohibited by law. We as Catholics believe that civil authorities must not condone vice, even implicitly.
For the Popeor any Catholicto endorse same-sex civil unions is wicked. It follows the exact same logic that Joe Biden uses to justify his support for abortion: Im personally opposed to killing babies in the womb, but I wouldnt impose that view on women who want to kill their babies. The Pope has just made that exact same argument for male sodomy.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
❧
This may be the most significant moment in papal history since Paul VI published Humanae Vitae. In fact, Franciss comments are a kind of diabolical inversion of Humanae Vitae.
When he ruled that artificial contraception was always and everywhere immoral, Paul VI was addressing a live debate in the Church that had never been definitively resolved. And not only did he go against popular opinion: he contradicted many of his own leading theologians, including many conservatives. As for Francis, nobody was expecting him to weigh in on this matter. This was a spontaneous remark, and on a matter that has long been settled by Church authorities. Only a small handful of mainstream theologians and bishops have ever signaled their support for civil unions.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Paul defended the Magisterium against vast legions of Sexual Revolutionaries outside the Vatican walls and their many fifth-columnists within. Francis has raised the white flag to the Sexual Revolution without their firing so much as a peashooter in his direction.
Some Catholics will take this as proof that Francis is consciously working to subvert traditional Church teaching. Others will assume hes just theologically illiterate and, frankly, not very bright. Still others will conclude that hes prone to spouting off on topics he neither understands nor really cares to understand. Many think hes going senile, which might be the most charitable view. But Ill leave that for the reader to decide.
At some level, it doesnt matter. Whether the Pope is consciously or accidentally dissenting from the Church, he is dissenting from the Church. Theres no question about that.
Little wonder that progressive Catholics are thrilled by the Popes comments. Father James Martin, who has long worked to undermine the Churchs teachings on homosexuality, tweeted: This is a major step forward in the churchs support for LGBTQ people. His colleague at the Jesuit-run America Magazine, Michael J. OLoughlin, likewise wrote: People downplaying the Popes words, on camera, endorsing civil unions for gay couples should ask LGBT Catholics how the remarks make them feel . I assure you this is big news. Indeed, it is.
Of course, the Catholic Left will weaponize the Popes comments against orthodox believers. Father Daniel Horan, the wayward Franciscan, wonders what bigoted church leaders who have been firing Catholic school teachers and parish ministers for entering into same-sex unions are thinking right now. Maybe theyre thinking about what their own resignation letters might look like. No doubt. Progressive bishops and diocesan bureaucrats will use Franciss endorsement as a cudgel against orthodox Catholics in our schools, colleges, and chanceries.
Whats astonishing is how many conservative Catholics cant see that. Ryan T. Anderson, who gained prominence as a critic of Big Trans and now teaches at the University of Dallas, also took to Twitter in support of Francis. Dr Anderson noted that he himself had also proposed something like civil unions for non-married people. Again, one tries to give Francis the benefit of the doubt. But that clearly crosses the line into cognitive dissonance.
❧
Francis may be one of those fifth-columnists that Paul VI opposed. Or maybe hes one of their useful idiots. But this much is perfectly clear: Pope Francis doesnt think of himself as pope. Whatever his idea of the papacy is, hes dead wrong.
The duty of the pope is to safeguard and clarify the Sacred Deposit of the Faith. Hes supposed to think with the mind of the Church and follow the Magisterium; instead, he speaks whatever happens to be on his mind and expects the Magisterium to follow. The papacy hasnt humbled him, as it did his predecessor. It has emboldened him.
Francis embraces the worst Protestant caricature of his office. He sees himself as a man with universal competence, one given to him directly by God Himself. That competence allows him to opine authoritatively on any matter, sacred or secular, that happens to tickle his fancy. Thats not what a pope is, by any stretch of the Catholic imagination.
But we know that. We also know that, when the Pope flatly contradicts the Magisterium, we may ignore him. Better yet, we canand we mustcontradict him loudly, for the sake of those who might otherwise follow the Holy Father into error. This isnt what the Church teaches, we say. This isnt what Catholics believe.
What a horrible burden this pope has put on the faithful. A good Catholic wants nothing more than to respect, trust, and obey the Successor of Saint Peter. Francis has made that impossible for so many. If he were really as wise and compassionate as he believes himself to be, he would recognize how many of his poor children hes leading into scandal and disbelief.
Yet sometimes a dutiful son can do nothing but resolve to be a bigger man than his father. And thats the sad situation we now find ourselves in. Pope Francis is leading our family down a dangerous path, and we cant accompany him on that journey. We have to plant our feet firmly in the Churchs sacred traditions, and encourage our brothers and sisters to do the same.
Pray for our Holy Father, who needs our prayers now more than ever. If you love him, stand your ground. Please God, hell turn away from his error someday. Then we, the faithful remnant, may lead him back home.
The duty of the pope is to safeguard and clarify the Sacred Deposit of the Faith. Hes supposed to think with the mind of the Church and follow the Magisterium; instead, he speaks whatever happens to be on his mind and expects the Magisterium to follow. The papacy hasnt humbled him, as it did his predecessor. It has emboldened him.
For the Popeor any Catholicto endorse same-sex civil unions is wicked. It follows the exact same logic that Joe Biden uses to justify his support for abortion: Im personally opposed to killing babies in the womb, but I wouldnt impose that view on women who want to kill their babies. The Pope has just made that exact same argument for male sodomy.
Ping
A good many people have been saying this for years. Sadly, not nearly enough people. This man is the Anti-Pope. A Heretic.
Remove Frank the Great Pretender. Restore Benedict.
Well thank God it couldn’t be any easier to decide whom to vote for, for POTUS.
The pro life one.
It might not be huge, but Catholics will vote majority Trump and we will win the election.
If we can’t change the pope, at least we can keep our president.
I will remained focused on Christ.
Bet your bottom dollar this charlatan takes it up the khyber. The whole practice of two men engaged in sodomy is a complete mockery of the church being a bride and Christ the groom. Man and woman speaks of life. The poop shute speaks of death and corruption.
Not true. The Catholics I work with are pro choice and are voting for Biden.
The same Catholics who voted for Obama are voting Biden.
May God forgive them.
They’re not Catholics.
I don’t know what is so hard to understand about that.
What makes someone Catholic is following the basic tenets of it.
Not being born into it or saying you are.
“i’m superman” It’s so easy to say.
But i’m not.
Catholics will vote majority Trump and save the day.
Have a good one :)
It’s clear that it’s unclear . For a pope that’s a wrong way
This antichrist has one lung and no brain.
Why “restore” a 93-year old who quit? Need a NEW Pope, a LION.
Tell the Pope you are sheep, not lemmings.
Cardinal Robert Sarah is about the only other individual high enough that could step in that would restore the papacy.
You need a pope whose dogma lives loudly within.
Can someone be pope and a US Supreme Court justice and a woman?
I know. The whole essence of being Catholic is abiding by its tenets. 1000%. Otherwise, you are not Catholic.
But for some reason these people feel they are exemplary Catholics?! How can that be? And how can so many Catholics have voted for Obama?
I am NOT a Catholic basher . Just so frustrated over what is happening to my fellow believers. (I am a non-denominational Christian.)
LOL! Let’s be Frank. Is the pope catholic...or does some other philosophy/sect over-ride his mental faculties?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G333Is7VPOg
Can someone be pope and a US Supreme Court justice and a woman?
https://duckduckgo.com/?q=John+Roberts&t=osx&iax=images&ia=images
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Roberts
https://duckduckgo.com/?q=amy+coney+barrett&t=osx&iax=images&ia=images
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amy_Coney_Barrett
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z8alr_XJ0co
Who separated you from you? Do you want to see a miracle? Look in the mirror. Look at your children, your parents, your grandparents. Look at your pets. Go outside. Look. Listen.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.