Posted on 12/04/2014 3:32:15 PM PST by NYer
As I wrote in my last post, many people have shown interest in buying my new book The Prodigal You Love: Inviting Loved Ones Back to the Church for their friends and family who are away from the Church. Even though they are not the intended audience, I do think the content of my book would be helpful to some fallen-away Catholics.
However, as many of you know, a book written by an atheist-turned nun is not going to speak to every fallen-away Catholic out there. So with the help of some of my friends who have also returned to the Church after being away, I wrote a post with the Top Ten Books for Fallen-Away Catholics. Because some folks are just not readers and we are approaching the family movie-watching season, I decided to follow up my previous post with a list of the top ten movies I would recommend seeing with or giving to the fallen-away Catholics you love.
With the help of some of my former fallen-away Catholic friends, here is the list in no particular order:
1. Of Gods and Men: This movie is about a group of Trappist monks who lived in the Algerian Mountains in harmony with the largely Muslim population of the town. Extremist groups are active in the area and the increasing violence forces the monks to decide whether to leave the people they have served for many years. This movie captures the beauty and radicality of religious life, but without sermons. As A.O. Scott put it in his New York Times Review: “The theme may be piety, but Mr. Beauvois and his cast do not address it piously.” There is genuine, real character to all of the monks interactions. Holiness and faith is certainly depicted, but not caricatured or simplified.
2. The Tree of Life: People either love or hate this film so I can’t guarantee your loved ones will like this movie. But I was really wowed by the innovative exploration of the themes of nature and grace in this movie directed by Terrence Malick. It is hard to describe this movie except to say that it is a poem in the form of a film. Everyone experiences the film in different ways because much of it is visual so I believe, if someone is open, it can bring them to contemplate the biggest questions in life, without clear boundaries or answers – something I think many non-practicing Catholics would appreciate. However, at the same time that this film allows for a wide variety of interpretation, it is firmly rooted in the primary dynamics of our faith.
3. Gandhi: This movie was among the top 45 films chosen by the Vatican to celebrate the 100th anniversary of film. I think it is a good choice for fallen-away Catholics because it depicts many Christian values, particularly a vision of justice and peace that is appealing and in line with Catholic teaching. It also shows the life of someone who lived for something beyond himself, and although he was not Catholic, this could actually be a positive because sometimes fallen-away Catholics are more open to stories of spirituality and holiness that are outside their realm of experience. Less baggage.
4. Into Great Silence: I don’t know what it is about movies about monks but secular people like them. I watched Into Great Silence at the very beginning of my conversion and I was really moved by how just watching this film was a prayerful, contemplative experience. If your loved one is into art, the cinematography in this movie is absolutely breathtaking. And if your loved ones is into Eastern meditation practices, movies like this reveal the deep contemplative tradition of the Church of which many people are often unaware.
5. Entertaining Angels: This is another film that would complement Gandhi. It is about Servant of God Dorothy Day and her tireless work for the poor. The movie is not preachy but the religious dimension is real and I think the radical life of Dorothy appeals to those who are on the fringes of the Church. After becoming Catholic, Dorothy Day did not lose her passion or even many of her radical views. She simply centered all that she was on the Gospel. Her story is inspiring and hopeful for many who find themselves on the fringes of the Church.
6. The Island (Ostr0v): This Russian film is not for everyone. I am not sure it would be moving to fallen-away Catholics who are not spiritual at all. But I do think the film has the potential to deeply touch a person. The star of the movie is a Russian rock star who converted to Orthodox Christianity and then moved away from fame to an isolated village. Some say the eccentric monk he plays is very similar to his actual personality. The movie centers on an Eastern Orthodox monk who is a fool for Christ. He is given to strange behavior but is also able to see the future and heal. The film is an intelligent and fascinating exploration of holiness, sin, attachment and forgiveness.
7. The Scarlet and the Black: This is one of my all-time favorite movies. This classic is based on the real story of a priest who saved thousands of Jews and Allied prisoners during the Nazi occupation of Italy. The character of Monsignor O’Flaherty, played flawlessly by Gregory Peck, is the highlight of the movie. He is humorous, lighthearted and at the same time courageous and bold. The movie does not preach the faith, but the holiness and the selfless actions of the main character do.
8. The Immigrant: This movie starring Marion Cotillard and Joaquin Phoenix depicts the unfortunate circumstances that drive Ewa, a young Polish immigrant woman, into prostitution. The movie is set in 1921 but it is a reminder of the difficulties immigrants face in any time. Throughout the film, Ewa calls out to Mary for help and relies on her Catholic faith despite her circumstances. There is a moving scene when Ewa goes to confession that serves as the turning point in the plot. In the end, the least likely people are found to be acting in Christ-like ways and it is a reminder that God can give grace to whomever he pleases in the most unlikely of circumstances.
9. The Mission: This movie with Jeremy Irons and Robert De Niro depicts the life of Jesuit missionaries in South America in the 18th century. About redemption, forgiveness, martyrdom, and grace, this film also touches on the rights of indigenous peoples and justice. If you watch this movie and don’t have something to talk or discuss with someone, then you may have inadvertently closed your eyes during most of the film. The Mission brings up so many theological and spiritual issues but does not tie them in a neat little bow at the end. This is a film that demands reflection and discussion, and both are helpful to engage in with fallen-away Catholics.
10. Les Misérables: Some may wonder why I would recommend a movie based on a story written by a fallen-away Catholic. One could call Victor Hugo the father of the “spiritual but not religious” crowd we see so much of these days. However, Hugo’s own work is evidence to the contrary. His story is drenched in Catholic themes and is a testament to the faith he rejected, (insert prayer for his soul here). Many of you have probably seen the recent movie adaptation of the musical that was released in 2012, but I actually prefer the movie from 1998. The scene when Valjean is returned to the bishop in chains is a poignant depiction of the Father’s forgiveness in the parable of the Prodigal Son. No matter how many times I watch this particular scene, it moves me and it just may move your fallen-away friends and family.
If you have any additions and suggestions, please feel free to add them in the comments!
As Christmas approaches, your fallen-away loved ones are in my prayers and the prayers of all the Daughters of St. Paul.
If you have friends and family who have fallen away from the Church, please consider picking up a copy of my book The Prodigal You Love: Inviting Loved Ones Back to the Church. It will help you journey with and invite your loved ones back to the Church.
No, I'm just saying it like it is.
ABSOLUTELY!
Also, the Bishop’s Wife, and perhaps An Affair to Remember...
While I’m not sure if it qualifies for the top 10, I would begrudgingly give honorable mention to Martin Sheen and Emilio Estevez’s, “The Way.”
I loved Hayley Mills. Let’s play the “Glad game”! :)
Anyone who claims you are Catholic because you were forced to make your first communion does not know what they are talking about. What religion you practice should always be a free will choice and not something anyone is coerced into. I am assuming you decided not to be confirmed. Shame on those who have misrepresented the Catholic faith to you.
I am assuming you are being sarcastic when you mention grape juice because Catholic priests use wine in a communion chalice. If it was indeed unfermented grape juice then you were not at a Catholic church.
May God bring you peace and bless you in however you may decide to follow him
It involved a woman who was conflicted about her choices during a particularly difficult time in history. I was quite young when I saw it, but I appreciated her attempt to do the right thing, despite everything that was happening around her.
She was human, and while she made some mistakes, I believed that she was trying to do her best.
Yes, I agree!
If someone had fallen away I would suggest..
1. The Chronicles of Narnia...The lion the witch and the wardrobe
2. Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade
People who have left the church are not going to be open to blatantly religious films, conversions of the heart are slow simmering affairs and gentle reminders from “main stream” film is a good place to start.
In Narnia we see what happens to Edmund when he rejects his family and God...he must repent ( remember he confesses to Aslan)
Indiana jones and the last crusade is fantastic in the end scenes when Indie must find the cup to save Sean Connery... even some old testament Hebrew lesson to remind us of sacred scripture followed by the humility of Jesus when he is able to discern the “cup of a carpenter” Good stuff.
I am assuming you are being sarcastic when you mention grape juice because Catholic priests use wine in a communion chalice. If it was indeed unfermented grape juice then you were not at a Catholic church.
Not sure what confirmation is, but I have no recollection of such a thing. We rarely went to church and I stopped altogether shortly afterwords. As for the grape juice, that's what I'm familiar with in Protestant churches. I may well have been given wine, but that was a long time ago. I'm surprised that states would allow alcohol to be given to minors.
“The Keys of the Kingdom” is one of my favorites.
You would remember having been confirmed. Confirmation is one of the sacraments of the Catholic tradition.
Children ( most often teenagers but there is some variation) receive according to Catholic beliefs the gifts and fruits of The Holy Spirit after a period of preparation. It is a way older children re-affirm their faith and make a conscious decision to continue to grow in their catholic faith.
Yes, Catholic churches do offer wine as an option to all those who have made their first communion. It is not against any laws for the church to do this, for this falls under religious freedom clauses. Also, drinking the wine in a Catholic Church is never mandatory as the host is believed to be the whole ( body blood and divinity of Jesus) and nothing more is required. Finally, it is not even required that a Catholic receive the Eucharist more than once a year. Going to mass every Sunday is however considered a moral obligation.
I apologize for the long winded answer, however understanding the belief systems of others sometimes helps us to understand where they are coming from even if we disagree.
Were you baptized in a Catholic Church?
Please answer the question.
I am not a rabid Catholic. Why do you issue personal attacks?
I am not a Catholic. Why do you insult me by saying I am? I find it very offensive to be called a catholic. And then you feel the need to rat on me to the religious moderator. Are you that insecure about your catholicism?
Please answer the question.
I have no idea. And regardless, it would have been done without my consent or voluntary participation. There is no biblical basis for what the catholic church does. It can make up whatever rules it wants, but if someone doesn't want to play, they have no effect. You are what you feel in your heart. And in my heart I am not a catholic. If you can't accept that, then you're the one with a problem, not me.
I’m so sorry you are rejecting God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit. I will say a prayer for you.
I reject catholicism. Being a Protestant does not mean you are rejecting God.
The term ‘rabid’ means extremely so. It is not insult to one whose faith comes first.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.