Posted on 10/25/2012 5:10:33 PM PDT by markomalley
Republican vice presidential candidate Paul Ryan said Oct. 24 that he believes reforming poverty aid programs and allowing religious and civil institutions to flourish is the most effective and compassionate way to help the millions of Americans in poverty.
“Americans are a compassionate people, and there’s a consensus in this country about our fundamental obligations to society’s most vulnerable,” he said in a policy address at Cleveland State University on Wednesday.
“Those obligations are not what we are debating in politics,” he explained. “Most times, the real debate is about whether they are best met by private groups or by the government.”
Ryan argued that the poor will receive more relief from “a dynamic, free-enterprise-based economy that fosters economic growth and opportunity and upward mobility” than from expansive federal government programs.
The Wisconsin congressman – who is Catholic – has faced criticism from numerous poverty relief groups over his recent budget proposal, which would cut funding levels of several prominent social aid programs.
Ryan rejected accusations that he believes the poor should be left to “fend for themselves.” Rather, he argued that he believes in “true compassion and upward mobility” based on “real reforms for lifting people out of poverty.”
A country’s compassion is not simply measured by how much the federal government spends, he said, calling for Americans to “take a hard look” at the federal government’s approach to poverty in the last 50 years, which he described as “centralized, bureaucratic, top-down.”
This system has caused problems, he said, leading to dependency and harming families and communities. These problems became so apparent that by the 1990s a major welfare reform law was “passed by a Republican Congress and signed by a Democratic president,” he noted.
Ryan argued that the reforms were successful, leading to lower welfare enrollment without increases in hunger or poverty. Millions of Americans achieved greater levels of independence, while employment levels for single mothers rose and child poverty rates fell more than 20 percent in four years.
Due to their success, the congressman asserted, these reforms should be applied to other anti-poverty programs as well.
“In most of these programs, especially in recent years, we’re still trying to measure compassion by how much government spends, not by how many people we help escape from poverty,” he said.
In the past year, Ryan said, the federal and state governments spent the equivalent of $22,000 per poor American on need-based programs. Yet one in six Americans remains in poverty, and the number of food stamp recipients has increased by 15 million in recent years.
Ryan promoted helping those in poverty by more efficiently using funding and giving states more power to tailor anti-poverty programs to fit “the unique needs of their citizens.”
This approach was beneficial when applied to welfare and can also be used in Medicaid and food stamps, he said.
“The federal government would continue to provide the resources, but we would remove endless federal mandates and restrictions that hamper state efforts to make these programs more effective,” he explained.
Ryan also underscored the need for strong communities.
He explained that “there has to be a balance – allowing government to act for the common good, while leaving private groups free to do the work that only they can do.”
Civil society – defined as families, neighborhoods, churches, charities and private associations – makes up the “vast middle ground between the government and the individual.”
These institutions are critical because they are “where we live our lives,” he said. “They shape our character, give our lives direction, and help make us a self-governing people.”
Ryan told stories of communities rallying around those in need during times of trouble.
“What’s really at work here is the spirit of the Lord, and there is no end to the good that it can inspire,” he said. “Government can’t replace that.”
Rather, he said, government must respect the rights and freedom of institutions that perform “essential and honorable work” in society.
But standing in contrast to that vision of government and society is the federal mandate that requires Catholic hospitals, charities and universities to violate their principles by offering contraception, sterilization and related products in their health insurance plans.
“This mandate isn’t just a threat to religious charities. It’s a threat to all those who turn to them in times of need,” the congressman said. “In the name of strengthening our safety net, this mandate and others will weaken it.”
Instead of “more taxes and coercive mandates,” he said, there must be a greater respect for the work of private associations in aiding the poor in ways that government alone cannot.
I do not believe in programs for the poor. I believe in wealth programs. Give everyone the tools to be wealthy. That will make America the one nation in the world that the highest standard of living for its low income earners.
In reality, today there are few poor people in our nation based on global standards. We waste a trillion dollars per year keeping people in so-called poverty.
Every penny is run through agency after agency so it takes more and more of your tax dollars.
Paul Ryan Rocks Dubuque
Paul Ryan Exclusive: Explains How His Catholic Faith Shapes Public Policy Views
Ryan highlights role of faith in his political views
Does Paul Ryan Want to Take Medicare Away From Seniors?[It's OK, Grandma, he's not a meany]
Cardinal Dolan’s Paul Ryan Problem [Amy Sullivan rant]
Paul Ryan at Prayer
With Ryan on the Ticket, Spotlight Focuses on the Catholic Church
Does Ryan have a “Catholic problem”?
Paul Ryan Urges Catholics to Act Before Religious Freedoms Erode
Wisconsin bishop praises Paul Ryan, discusses intrinsic evils, prudential judgments
Paul Ryan urges Catholics to act before religious freedoms erode
Dolan: Ryan Is a ‘Great Public Servant’ (great insight into Ryan's views)
Paul Ryan’s Bishop Defends Him Amid Attacks on His Application of Church Teaching
Paul Ryan, Catholic Who Looks to Church's Social Teaching, Tapped as Romney Running Mate
The other Ryan: the candidate’s wife, Janna
Paul Ryan, Joe Biden, and Liberal False Equivalence
Ryan as VP Pick Continues Election Year Focus on Catholicism
Paul Ryan Faces Left-Wing Religious Attack
Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Holiness (Paul Ryan)
Paul Ryan: Midwesterner, Catholic, intellectual
I was a pretty strong liberal & I admit I was starting to have misgivings on an economic level. After 17 years in private schools I switched 7 years ago to a public system in a low income identified district w/ seemingly unlimited spending.
I have to say that is where my eyes fianlly were opened wide. Unless you have worked in the public sector; health dept., school district, welfare office...........you really have NO idea of the fraud & abuse & generational abuse of the system. I reluctantly voted for Obama in 2008 and I will NEVER make a mistake like that again.
I work for Pennsylvania's governor, I won't go into too many details, due to my position. I have full understanding of the complete waste. The mission of my current job is to convince Republicans that they can cut waste.
Most politicians have zero principles or business experience. They don't get it. I know Romney has business experience, I hope he has the right principles. Obama has zero business experience, and I know he has the absolutely worst principles. The choice is clear, no reason to lean.
Fewer dollars going to the government means more to go to private bodies. But the attitude among liberals is suggested by the efforts to bully Walmart into preventing the Salvation Army from putting bell-wrings at their doors during Xmas season.
Ryan! Ryan!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.