Posted on 01/31/2020 5:23:03 AM PST by Kaslin
It's unlikely that Donald Trump's new Israeli-Palestinian peace plan will succeed. Yet, it's the best of any recent offerings because it dispels poisonous fictions that have held back negotiations for decades.
The reality is that there will never be a Palestinian "right of return" to Israel, since such a policy would destroy the Jewish character of the state. Palestinians are not getting their great-granddads' houses in Jaffa back any more than the hundreds of thousands of Sephardic Jews who were expelled from Muslim lands after Israel's 1948 war of independence are reclaiming their property. The difference is that one of these groups accepted reality long ago.
Nor will Palestinians ever take control of Jerusalem proper. Any Israeli politician who broaches the notion of handing over the fulcrum of Jewish cultural, religious and political identity to Fatah is engaging in an act of political suicide. Palestinians have never administered Jerusalem, and they have no legitimate claim over Jerusalem. The current state of affairs is the status quo, whether Palestinians decide they want a state or not.
Likewise, Israelis will never pull back to pre-1967 lines, giving up its claims to the West Bank, because no sane nation would reinstitute unsecure borders next to an unreliable potential terror state. The vast majority of Israelis who now reside in towns ("settlements") built in historically Jewish areas aren't going to be displaced because the United Nations or Ben Rhodes has declared Judea and Samaria a no-Jew zone. Those towns are part of a de facto border whether Palestinians agree to a deal or not.
Finally, there is no way that Israel, a liberal democracy responsible for the security of its citizens, can hand over the Jordan Valley -- an area with immense strategic importance irrespective of the Palestinian situation -- to a newly created state that allies itself with unsavory nations and entertains the idea of entering into a unity government with Hamas, the theocratic terror group. Perhaps, after peaceful coexistence for a few decades, this could change.
The Trump deal would simply codify these realities while allowing Palestinians to finally have a startup state. Trump's plan is the first to offer a map laying out what the final borders of the Palestinian nation might look like. In it, Israel cedes around 70% of the disputed territory in the West Bank to Palestinians but doubles its existing territory overall. "The sovereign capital of the State of Palestine," the plan states, would be the city of "East Jerusalem."
In return, Palestinians would recognize the existence of Israel, agree to solve their refugee problem through integration in their new state and in host Arab counties, and renounce terrorism. In other words, Palestinians would be asked to conduct themselves as does any normal, functioning state. The U.S. would also infuse $50 billion into the new Palestinian state.
Stateless peoples yearning for self-determination around the world -- ethnic groups that Western elites don't care a whit about -- would, no doubt, be ecstatic for such an opportunity. Palestinians, however, happen to have chosen the right enemies.
They just have the wrong leaders. President Mahmoud Abbas hasn't faced an electorate in 15 years and counting. His title of "president" falsely suggests that Abbas is the duly elected leader of a nation. Neither is true. And while that is his own fault, Abbas and his deputies will no doubt sit in their U.N.-funded mansions while the Palestinian people suffer, waiting out Trump for more advantageous terms from a friendlier president such as Joe Biden -- or Bernie Sanders, who could put Linda Sarsour in his administration.
But they won't be able to wait out Israel. A nation with an open and vibrant economy has no reason to enter into a deal that upends its security. Most Israelis -- I hate to break this to everyone -- aren't obsessed with the Palestinians. Hamas is largely contained. Fatah is contained. Israel's existence isn't contingent on the creation of a Palestinian state, only on security.
Israel, in fact, probably feels less external pressure than ever to enter into a deal. Anyone who's followed this issue understands the historic significance of Bahrain, UAE, and Oman sending envoys to White House unveiling of Trump's peace deal. Arab nations are coming to terms with the reality of the Jewish State in ways that Americans progressives have not.
Nor is there more internal political pressure to enter into a bad deal. Benny Gantz, the Kahol Lavan leader and chief rival to Benjamin Netanyahu, "hailed" the Trump plan because, despite the effort of the American left to cast Netanyahu as the sole impediment to peace, no major Israeli party on either the right or the left is going to agree to a right of return, a return to pre-1967 lines, or a surrender of Jerusalem.
In the past, Palestinian negotiators sat back and rejected one concession after the next. They offered ever-growing lists of grievances while American leaders tried to pacify them. It's about time someone injected a dose of this reality into this situation. Trump's plan allows Palestinians to have a state in the world that exists. Or not.
The plan now puts the onus on those who would be Palestinians to recognize Israel and renounce violence to get a seat at the table. Rather than the present game where Israel concedes much just to talk.
A massive victory as it extracts us from a long quagmire. Our cards are also all out on the table.
Economic pressure and isolation, along with neighboring Arab countries supporting the plan will win the day.
Everybody knows that it will be , in fact already has been , rejected
So long as there is Iran, there will never be Palestine
Who keeps the crazies in line. Abbas? More likely the jooz. Violently. So much for peace.
So long as the Euro rules of war are in effect, there will be no peace between the Palestinians and Israel.
War is definitive. The losers are killed and economically destroyed.
The European rules of war prohibit killing. Absent war there is no peace.
..................
Here’s my peace plan. The Palestinians all move to East Palestine (Jordan) and Israel takes back the Gaza Strip and gets all of the West Bank. The Capital of Israel is Jerusalem and the Capital of East Palestine is Amman.
The Fakestinians will never accept a plan that does not drive Israel into the sea.
I hope it works, but I suspect that peace in that region will only be achieved when the last Muslim is dead.
No. The difference is that one of those groups was forced out and the other was asked not to leave but told if they did they would not be allowed back in because they had sided with the enemy.
The mohammedans who were residents at that time were asked to stay by the Israeli government. Their "brothers" told them that if they left they would have their pick of the loot when the mohammedans crushed the new nation. They were lying but that is expected.
The ones that stayed became citizens, voters and property owners. Those that left abandon their property.
They were thrown out of Jordan back in the early 70s. People get so upset when you try to kill the royal family and take over.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.