Skip to comments.Is Israel the Problem, or Are Jews the Problem?
Posted on 02/18/2015 5:38:49 AM PST by SJackson
In the aftermath of the killing of a man at a Copenhagen synagogue by a member of the Religion of Peace, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said, This wave of attacks is expected to continue. Jews deserve security in every country, but we say to our Jewish brothers and sisters, Israel is your home. Russian emigre Natan Sharansky echoed Netanyahus call, stating, There is no future for Jews in western Europe.
In response, European leaders shouted down Netanyahu. We know there are doubts, questions across the community, said French President Francois Hollande, who was elected with in excess of 93 percent of the Muslim vote. I will not just let what was said in Israel pass, leading people to believe that Jews no longer have a place in Europe and France, in particular. The same week, Jewish tombstones were spray-painted by the hundreds in eastern France.
But undoubtedly, European anti-Semites will now claim that Netanyahus comments simply demonstrate why Europe must force out its Jews: because Israel is just so awful. That, at least, is what a German court in the city of Wuppertal concluded after convicting two German Palestinians of setting fire to a synagogue. The Wuppertal court stated that the men were simply attempting to bring attention to the Gaza conflict. In other words, Jews are fair game because of Israel.
But its precisely the reverse that is true: Israel is fair game because it is Jewish. This is the dirty little secret of anti-Israel policy: It is almost entirely anti-Semitic policy. That is why Muslims attack Jewish synagogues in Paris during the Gaza war: because Israel is a stand-in for the Jews, not the other way around. Were Israel a Muslim country, the rest of the world would see it as a beacon of light and hope for the future of an entire religion.
Because it is Jewish, Muslims target it for destruction, and the rest of the world tut-tuts Israels nasty habit of attempting to survive. The extra-American world hates Israel because it is Jewish. It does not hate Jews because of Israel. Israel is merely a convenient excuse.
Ironically, radical Muslims, in targeting Jews throughout the world, reinforce the necessity of a state of Israel. Their argument seems to be that Israel is an unnecessary Jewish nationalist cancer; to prove that argument, they suggest killing Jews all over the planet, leaving no place safe for Jews except for Israel.
And so Jews go to Israel by the droves. European governments can rip Netanyahu all they want for his supposedly brusque dismissal of European tolerance, but that supposed tolerance means less and less when Swedish Jews abandon entire cities as the authorities make way for radical Muslims. European governments can condemn the Gaza war, but Jews see that war for what it was: an exercise in Jewish self-preservation, with the Europeans once again attempting to prevent such self-preservation.
Unlike the Europeans, Americans continue to side with Israel because America is founded on Judeo-Christian principles. America embraces Judaism, and so it embraces Israel, not the other way around. The formula is simple: Love Jews; love Israel. Hate Jews; hate Israel. Opposing Israeli action may not be anti-Semitism, but it sure does have a funny habit of backing the agenda of anti-Semites.
If youd like to be on or off, please FR mail me.
Let me get this straight - Israel or Jews - is there a difference?
Israel has a large community of Arabs.
Any Jew still living in Europe after the Holocaust is crazy.
Neither Israel nor Jews is the problem. Insufficient armed defense for Israel and Jews is the problem.
To start with, no other country in the world would tolerate having a hostile people within its borders, who attack its citizens, invite foreign powers to create war against that nation, as well as seek to divide that nation. And swear to both destroy the nation and slaughter its people.
Seriously, four large wars and other smaller ones have been leveled against Israel, yet Israel refuses to put an end to it. And don’t even think of calling it a “final solution”. Instead it would not even be a “cruel deportation”. Israel could *easily* pay every Paleo man, woman and child a substantial amount of money to move to Egypt or Jordan. AND THE PROBLEM WOULD BE OVER.
No more Israeli blood shed. No more terrorism in their borders. No more continual argument and brawl with the Paleos. There would finally be peace and prosperity. An end to the mess. Who cannot appreciate the simplicity and generosity of doing things this way?
The other solution is even easier. Jews around the world need to be armed. All the time. Carrying weapons should be part and parcel with being Jewish.
The ultra-Orthodox Jewish folks, with them, they will not chop your head off.
The only “problem” is ignorant and homicidal anti-semites, of which there are uncountable numbers around the world.
“... to move to Egypt or Jordan. AND THE PROBLEM WOULD BE OVER.”
Except none of the Arab countries will accept them. Further, this non-acceptance of muslims back into their country of origin from Israel is why there are the so-called refuge camps in Lebanon, etc.
No one wants the Palestinians!
Not to sound glib, but have you looked at the United States recently?
In other words, Jews are fair game because of Israel. But it's precisely the reverse that is true: Israel is fair game because it is Jewish. This is the dirty little secret of anti-Israel policy: It is almost entirely anti-Semitic policy. That is why Muslims attack Jewish synagogues in Paris during the Gaza war: because Israel is a stand-in for the Jews, not the other way around. Were Israel a Muslim country, the rest of the world would see it as a beacon of light and hope for the future of an entire religion. Because it is Jewish, Muslims target it for destruction, and the rest of the world tut-tuts Israel's nasty habit of attempting to survive. The extra-American world hates Israel because it is Jewish. It does not hate Jews because of Israel.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.