[Dr. Sivana]

Falwell’s lawsuit

I think that case was decided wrongly. Falwell was alive at the time of the libel against him. If Mohammad were still alive, and the French publication knowingly printed something libelous, I think he should be able to have an action.

[Slings and Arrows]

If Mohammad were still alive, and the French publication knowingly printed something libelous, I think he should be able to have an action.

Interesting point. Two thoughts on it:

1. As a public figure, Mohammed would have the bar set pretty high with respect to winning a libel case. Beyond that, he'd have to prove damages. (Note: IANAL. Not even close.)

2. Truth is a defense against libel. If you call him a murdering pedophile, all it means is you've read his book.