Skip to comments.Report: Immigration Bill Would Add Nearly 14,000 Jobs Per District [Lies, lies and more lies]
Posted on 08/20/2013 12:28:49 PM PDT by Jim Robinson
The Senates immigration bill would add nearly 14,000 new jobs on average in each congressional district over the next decade, according to a new report.
The new analysis is from the center-right American Action Network (AAN), which backs an overhaul of the nations immigration laws. Its being distributed to lawmakers offices as pro-reform groups seek to convince GOP congressmen to vote for immigration reform proposals this fall.
District-by-district data is available through this web tool. No district would see fewer than 7,000 jobs created by 2023, and an average of 13,992 new jobs would be created in each. The figures were compiled using data from a Regional Economic Models, Inc. (REMI) study of economic data and new worker visas and a Congressional Budget Office report on the impact of the Senate bill.
The figures could provide more cover for Republican House members who are considering backing reform. It could allow them to explain their position to skeptical constituents during August recess, when immigration has been a hot topic at town hall meetings.
Pro-reform conservatives have long framed immigration reform as a job-creation effort, dovetailing with the GOP message on jobs and the goals of party leaders to broaden that message to Latino voters.
(Excerpt) Read more at abcnews.go.com ...
Anyone pushing this economy-wrecking, job-killing, sovereignty-killing, treasonous Marxist propaganda is no conservative.
FUMR!! FUJM!! FULG!! TRAITORS!!
Unfortunately, they will all be government jobs providing welfare and other social benefits to the newly minted "citizens"...
.......while adding 35,000 job SEEKERS in each congressional district.
With 435 congressional districts, that comes out to more than 6,000,000 jobs.
I call “Complete BS” on this.
Sure it would. More obstetricians would be needed for all the new citizen anchor babies, you need more Department of Human Services to hand out more EBT cards, more police officers to arrest more gangbangers, etc...you clearly don’t know what you’re talking about.../s
BS...it’ll add 14 thousand JOB SEEKERS per congressional district.
And that's just in law enforcement!
NO doubt. The Prison industry would ballon.
Lets see. Fewer and fewer decent jobs for those without higher education. We can’t create jobs for those we already have in that quandary so by adding millions more of them that will somehow create jobs.
Anyone can take any set of numbers and extrapolate anything they wish.
There ain’t a shovel big enuf to tackle the mindset of idiocy, so deeply is it entrenched in politics and the media today.
Anything ABC says is 'center-right' is, in actuality, hardcore left.
This “study” is pure poop
Reading their model, it seems to me they’re saying that economic activity will increase because illegals doing under the table jobs will legalize, then they’ll get higher wages, and that will result in the nirvana of economic activity lifting everybody’s boats.
They don’t seem to allow for:
1. Under-the-table businesses not wanting to go legal and pay higher wages.
2. New illegals flooding in to take those under-the-table jobs at the same low wages, turning the new legals into unemployed welfare clients.
3. Higher unemployment and welfare costs
From the Remi report:
***We attribute the increase in wages following legalization to two causes, which we categorize as compliance and productivity. The first category, compliance, represents an increase in wages, without any productivity gains, that results from employers more closely conforming to labor legislation such as minimum wage and overtime requirements. The second category, labor productivity, represents pay increases that occur in conjunction with increases in labor productivity.***
And this is what passes for intelligence in Washington DC.
Their model on page 23 also says that employment is a function of them taking into account: (http://www.remi.com/download/Key%20Components%20of%20Immigration%20Reform.pdf)
all government spending, all consumer spending, all investment, all exports, and the entire domestic market.
And they plug whatever wild assumptions in and then come out with their number on employment.
How many millions of jobs did Pelosi promise as a result of Obamacare?
435 DISTRICTS x 14,000 JOBS = 6,090,000 = bs.............
Between the first quarter of 2000 and the first quarter of 2013, the native-born population accounted for two-thirds of overall growth in the working-age population (16 to 65), but none of the net growth in employment among the working-age has gone to natives.
The overall size of the working-age native-born population increased by 16.4 million from 2000 to 2013, yet the number of natives actually holding a job was 1.3 million lower in 2013 than 2000.
The total number of working-age immigrants (legal and illegal) increased 8.8 million and the number working rose 5.3 million between 2000 and 2013.
Even before the recession, when the economy was expanding (2000 to 2007), 60 percent of the net increase in employment among the working-age went to immigrants, even though they accounted for just 38 percent of population growth among the working-age population.
Since the jobs recovery began in 2010, about half the employment growth has gone to immigrants. However the share of working-age natives holding a job has remained virtually unchanged since 2010 and the number of working-age natives without a job (nearly 59 million) has not budged.
Well, it describes DC idiocy fairly well.
Liberal or RINO-nation for sure.
Norm Coleman (former Democrat), Fred Malek (McCain campaign, George HW Bush, assistant to Nixon), Brian O Walsh (?)...
AAN is Norm Coleman
He pushed for George W Bush’s amnesty very hard
The only jobs ObamaCare will create are government jobs. Well, maybe some low paying, part-time health care jobs (that used to be HIGH PAYING, FULL-TIME healthcare jobs). Will open up vast opportunities for fraud and corruption, though.
Once upon time we were told that Obamacare would reduce government liability and make insurance cheaper. Garbage in, garbage out.
Six million jobs in 10 years? I can see that. I just don’t think that their creation will be due to Shamesty.
AAN did not do any “study” they are pro-amnesty, they always have been. They are not non-partisan on this issue, never have been.
And Obama if your like your dr you can keep him..Same ones who said President Obama’s initial claim that the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) would cost $940 billion and now it’s up to Over $2 Trillion
.Anything projected here in few years will never achieve its original goal..All I know is these jobs are nothing but wishful thinking
Makes just as much sense as this article.
Any idiot who believes this deserves the government they vote for. The rest of us will suffer for it though, which really stinks!
In other news, the chocolate ration is being increased from 20 grams to 30 grams.
I live in Nevada. I don’t think we even have 14,000 persons in some of our Congressional Districts-—right now.
In Clark County- the majority of those are illegals. Who else would vote for Harry Reid?
Now start adding the number of new kids that will come across the border or will be born to new immigrants. No one talks about the impact on are already hard pressed schools and their budgets. The RATS would think it was great because they would want to higher a million new teachers who all pay does the RAT party.
This is a brand new scam!
these are not conservatives, these are squishy moderates at best and these same people were pushing for amnesty under Bush, so they have an agenda
I know what they are. I just never heard them identified that way. It is contemptible!
They are NOT conservatives, of course. Reminds me of “Zimmerman being a “white hispanic” : )
After amnesty, just double the number of congressional districts. That would create even more jobs :)
The Senates immigration bill would add nearly 14,000 new jobs on average in each congressional district over the next decade, according to a new report.14,000 amnestied illegals handing out money and benefits to the new illegals waiting for THEIR amnesty.
And I forgot to say, just think how many jobs we could create by letting a billion “immigrants” in from Africa, the middle east, South America, etc.
3.3 million new jobs for 20 million illegals? That is an 83% unemployment rate
Now that we found out that welfare pays better than many jobs pay, its obvious that we need these new ‘immigrants’ to do these jobs that Americans ‘wont do’ because get paid better to stay home and watch cable.
Until they learn of the scam and join the others. Drat, then we need another immigration bill.
Now I see the light.
” Drat, then we need another immigration bill.
Now I see the light. “
SJB Immigration Reform Bill.
Demand the House & Senate enforce the current laws, or we throw them in jail, and take their pensions.
Congress is not given authority to enforce laws, to just pass them.
That is the new CIR Bill.
My joke wasn’t funny. Sue me : )
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.