Posted on 04/01/2013 7:47:17 AM PDT by SeekAndFind
Yeah....not so much. When you start with a moronic premise like this one, you're conclusion is pretty much doomed. The US hasn't been remotely Randian in decades if ever, though the farther we get from it, the worser we do. I stand with The Won when he says that if a particular group or ideology mucked something up, they don't get to direct the fix. Course his application of the principle is 180 degrees out of phase with reality, but what the heck, at least he got SOMETHING right, eh?
I am not a huge fan of Rand’s ideology but she clearly points out that many many companies will join the looters. Nowhere does she say that all businesses are the good guys
This statement shows the author has gone FULL RETARD
Anthem reminds me of the Who song, 905.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n2ZOhWAaGVs
I bought that album “Who Are You” when it came out (still have it) and seeing Keith Moon sitting in a chair that has ‘not to be taken away’ written on it disturbing.
Rand’s philosophy is incoherent, sophomoric materialism, but her depiction of a future American fascist state was prophetic.
_______________
There are writers who help readers to escape preconceived notions and prejudices and assumptions. One might not find their whole developed system appealing, but they do help young people who are trying to break free and form their own opinions and beliefs about the world. You wouldn't want to take them as your guide in all things, but you're glad that they were around when you needed them.
I wish Ayn had realized that and hadn't tried to lay down the last word on everything once and for all for everyone. But if she had known that, she wouldn't have been Ayn Rand. It may have been the whole Russian woman thing.
“And this crisis was caused, to a great extent, by Randian economics.”
We’ve been in a Central Planned economy since FDR. Any glimpse of entrepreneurship has been pure dumb luck.
Rand knew human nature and behaviors. Past is prologue.
I went through a Rand phase when I was in my twenties. I must have read about ten of her books. She claimed many times to have been a disciple of Aristotle, but I can’t recall any evidence of it.
Rather than the Law of Non-Contradiction, her First Principle was the tautological formulation of A=A, and it was downhill from there. She never mentions Substance/accidents, the Four Causes, the virtues. etc.
http://www.aquinasonline.com/Topics/ is a great resource for anyone who is interested in common sense philosophy of Aristotle and St. Thomas.
There is a cult. It is known as Objectivism.
Most Freepers have never read Ayn Rand and have no clue what her philosophy is. Like oil and water, Ayn Rand and Free Republic don't mix.
exactly - why can’t we admire the stuff she got right.
And she was VERY right about socialists and communists.
And other stuff she got wrong.
Such is life
WE NEED SEPARATION OF GOVERNMENT FROM POWER!...............
“And this crisis was caused, to a great extent, by Randian economics. Eschewing traditional fiscal conservatism, the American Right embraced for the better part of three decades a messianic form of capitalism that demonized the state and society, while fostering an idolatry of the individual entrepreneur, the corporate CEO, and the unabashed pursuit of money as the highest moral good.”
No need to read further, this is complete and utter bull excrement.
“There’s no way to rule innocent men. The only power any government has is the power to crack down on criminals. Well, when there aren’t enough criminals, one makes them. One declares so many things to be a crime that it becomes impossible for men to live without breaking laws. Who wants a nation of law-abiding citizens? What’s there in that for anyone? But just pass the kind of laws that can neither be observed nor enforced nor objectively interpreted and you create a nation of law-breakers — and then you cash in on guilt. Now that’s the system.”
Quote by: Ayn Rand
(1905-1982) Author
Source: “Atlas Shrugged”, Part II, Chapter 3
I thought that was Toohey talking to Keating after he broke him in the Fountainhead.
But it sure sounds like what I was talking about. What character is saying this?
Yeah, I guess you could distill The Old Man and the Sea down to ten pages but at least Hemingway took the man’s way out.
Actually, I shouldn’t joke about suicide because the thought of people doing it depresses me. To think people thought jumping from the top of the WTC was the best choice is disturbing even though I might have joined them. Sorry for the buzzkill.
Hemingway also liked cats, a virtue indeed although he might have been a hoarder but his poly-dactyl kittehs are still around his place.
Then I invite you to read The Sound and The Fury if you haven't already and get back to me if you haven't gone insane. My teacher thought it was the best book written and I still see it on my shelf. I've read Rand books more than once but TSATF once was enough. Heck, I've read the Bell Jar more than once and it's barely comprehensive which might have been the point though.
I dislike deconstructing anything (except for cars to get parts that is).
I caught a big fish. He fought like hell. Here's his carcass..........
You left out that he was too big to fit in the boat as the reason only his carcass made it back.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.