Posted on 07/03/2010 6:43:19 AM PDT by 1rudeboy
In this essay, I argue that neither non-economist bloggers, nor economists who portray economics especially macroeconomic policy as a simple enterprise with clear conclusions, are likely to contibute any insight to discussion of economics and, as a result, should be ignored by an open-minded lay public.The following is a letter to open-minded consumers of the economics blogosphere. In the wake of the recent financial crisis, bloggers seem unable to resist commentating routinely about economic events. It may always have been thus, but in recent times, the manifold dimensions of the financial crisis and associated recession have given fillip to something bigger than a cottage industry. Examples include Matt Yglesias, John Stossel, Robert Samuelson, and Robert Reich. In what follows I will argue that it is exceedingly unlikely that these authors have anything interesting to say about economic policy. This sounds mean-spirited, but its not meant to be, and Ill explain why.
Before I continue, heres who I am: The relevant fact is that I work as a rank-and-file PhD economist operating within a central banking system. I have contributed no earth-shaking ideas to Economics and work fundamentally as a worker bee chipping away with known tools at portions of larger problems. It is precisely from this low-level vantage point that I am totally puzzled by the willingness of many who fearlessly and breathlessly opine about economics, especially macroeconomic policy. Deficits, short-term interest rate targets, sovereign debt are all chewed over with a level of self-assuredness that only someone who doesnt know more could. The list of those exhibiting this zest also includes, in addition to those mentioned above, some who might know better. They are the patron saints of the Macroeconomic Policy is Easy: Only Idiots Dont Think So movement: Paul Krugman and Brad Delong. Either of these men will assure their readers that its all really very simple (and may even be found in Keynes writings). Lastly, before you dismiss me as a right- or left-winger, I am not. Im simply less comfortable with ex cathedra pronouncements and speculations than the people I have named. [footnote omitted]
The main problem is that economics, and certainly macroeconomics is not, by any reasonable measure, simple. Macroeconomics is most narrowly concerned with the tracing of individual actions into aggregate outcomes, and most fatally attractive to bloggers: vice versa. What makes macroeconomics very complicated is that economic actors... act. Firms think about how to make profits, households think about how to budget their resources. And both sets of actors forecast. They must. One has to take a view on ones future income, health, and familial obligations to think about what to set aside for retirement, how much life insurance to buy, and so on. Of course, all parties may be terrible at forecasting, thats certainly a possibility, but thats not the issue. Even if one wanted to think of all economic actors as foolish and purposeless organisms making utterly random choices, one must accept that their decisions will still affect, and be affected by what others do. The finitude of resources ensures this accounting reality.
[excerpted]
It’s not a “self-evident truth,” nor is it a consequence of a self-evident truth, that this author should die. That’s where your trailer-park preaching falls . . . think of my response to it as someone telling you that your accessories don’t match.
What’s the self-evident truth and consequence of eating A$$Paper?
If the author doesn’t like the A$$Paper on his (Federal Reserve) employer’s menu, too bad - it’s not like Mr. Phd Suuuuper Genius & Co. weren’t warned.
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/warning/view/
Bon Appetit.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.