Posted on 02/23/2010 3:22:54 PM PST by wagglebee
February 23, 2010 (LifeSiteNews.com) – An Angus Reid poll released last week found that approximately two-thirds of Canadians nationwide support the legalization of euthanasia. At the same time, however, a prominent anti-euthanasia activist has questioned the results, saying that “there's still an awful lot of misunderstanding” about euthanasia.
The poll found that respondents from Quebec and British Columbia were most likely to support the legalization of euthanasia and assisted suicide. 67% of all respondents supported legalizing euthanasia, while 77% of respondents from Quebec supported legalization, and 75% of those from BC. Twenty-three percent of respondents opposed legalization.
Additionally, 48% disagreed with the statement that legalizing euthanasia would “leave vulnerable people without sufficient legal protection,” while 41% agreed.
Regarding assisted suicide, 43% stated that parents who help a terminally ill son or daughter to die should not be punished, and 41% thought any person who helps someone else commit suicide should not be prosecuted.
The poll also asked whether respondents thought that legalizing euthanasia would give those who are suffering an opportunity to ease their pain. 85% agreed, and 9% disagreed.
The poll was conducted between February 2nd and 3rd, through online interviews with 1,003 Canadian adults. The margin of error is 3.1 per cent.
Alex Schadenberg, executive director of the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition, told LifeSiteNews (LSN), however, that he does not consider “the poll results as being totally accurate.”
He explained that this is “not because I don't think there's a lot of support for euthanasia, because actually I know there is a fair amount, but because the Quebec physicians, for example, have been constantly talking about euthanasia as being the same thing as use of large doses of pain killers in palliative care, and, of course, that's not true.”
Schadenberg believes that ongoing statements from such bodies as the Quebec College of Physicians (CMQ) and the Federation of Quebec Medical Specialists (FMSQ) have exacerbated the confusion that exists around euthanasia.
Both the CMQ and the FMSQ have called for euthanasia to be legalized, while apparently arguing that the practice of palliative sedation is a form of euthanasia. Palliative sedation involves administering increasing doses of pain killers to terminally ill patients, and can result – often foreseeably, but unintentionally – with the death of the patient because ultimately lethal doses are required to control the pain.
The CMQ and FMSQ have both argued, as they did last week before the Quebec government's legislative committee examining euthanasia, that this practice, which has long been considered ethical by ethicists, could currently be considered illegal under Canadian law. While no doctors have been prosecuted, they insist that doctors fear the law.
Dr. Margaret Somerville, director of the Centre for Medicine, Ethics and Law at McGill University, refuted this claim in an op-ed on Tuesday in the Montreal Gazette. “Palliative means the sedative was necessary to relieve pain and suffering and was not given with an intention of killing the patient,” she wrote. “That cannot result in a murder charge, or any other legal charge, unless the patient refused it.”
Somerville added that the public's wishes shouldn't dictate the law. “Just because the public wants something or a majority votes for it doesn't mean it is ethical - or even wise,” she wrote. “Democratic decisions and ethical ones are not necessarily the same.”
Schadenberg made a similar comment regarding the current Angus Reid poll. “Just because a large group of people want it to happen, that doesn't help out the group of people who are threatened by it,” he said. He explained that many people who favour euthanasia are “thinking out of fear.”
“They're thinking of 'I don't want to experience what maybe my mother or my aunt or my friend did.',” he said. “And that's understandable. But we don't give doctors the right to directly and intentionally cause our death because of fear.”
“What I'm suggesting is that the majority of Canadians don't actually understand the question,” Schadenberg reiterated. “If they did, they would feel far more unsettled.”
An October Environics poll commissioned by LifeCanada revealed a majority supporting euthanasia, but also seemed to indicate that Canadians are conflicted on the issue. While 61% stated support for legalization, 70% indicated that they were worried that if euthanasia were legalized, patients would be euthanized without their consent. Additionally, 69% said that the government's priority should be improving palliative care, while only 18% wanted legalization as the priority.
LifeSiteNews did not hear back from Angus Reid by press time.
See related LifeSiteNews.com coverage:
Quebec Doctors Want their Euthanasia Practices Acknowledged, Legalized
http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2010/feb/10021606.html
Pro-Life MP Disappointed that Vote on Euthanasia Bill Has Been Delayed Again
http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2009/dec/09120306.html
New Poll Reveals that Canadians are Conflicted About Legal Euthanasia
http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2009/nov/09110301.html
Anti-Euthanasia Group Questions Survey Suggesting Quebec MDs are Favorable to Euthanasia
http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2009/oct/09101404.html
Anti-Euthanasia Group Questions Survey Suggesting Quebec MDs are Favorable to Euthanasia
http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2009/oct/09101404.html
Pro-Life Ping
Freepmail wagglebee to subscribe or unsubscribe from the moral absolutes ping list.
FreeRepublic moral absolutes keyword search
Filed in the “Yes, life is that bad in Canada” department.
Sure why not, save a few bucks on health care. I just want to know who decides who dies and who lives.
Socialism takes blessings and turns them into curses - babies, old folks, etc.
Ping
If people were more educated about what euthanasia really means and what it inevitably leads to, it wouldn’t be so popular. If that figures are even correct.
Well, I can see where living in Canada could lead most people to consider suicide on demand. Sorta like Norway without the fjords, saunas, and high percentage of blonds.
“...67% of all respondents supported legalizing euthanasia, while 77% of respondents from Quebec supported legalization, and 75% of those from BC.”
I think that those folks need to show their support for euthanasia by stepping up to the plate and literally take a bullet for the team.
It ain’t gonna be you, and those making the decisions won’t be getting it in the neck anytime soon.
Don’t be too disgusted.... less and less support it every day. Why is that?
*************************
That sounds very likely. I wonder what the quality of TV and newspaper reporting is?
If I lived in Canada, after enduring a few of those winters, I’d want someone to do me in, too!
(Is this the result of govt run health care? “You are worthless, we don’t want to pay for your care anymore so off you go”?...nice...)
This is most likely an "I support it on paper for everyone else, but when it comes to ME.." sort of issue.
My Brother in law relinquished his US citizenship and is now a Canadian. Professor of Ethics doncha know, who went on sabbatical in the Netherlands to study this very subject. His thesis on the subject sits on my inlaws' coffee table.
The eldest, the brilliant golden child who can otherwise do no wrong is NOT, however, my in laws' Power of Attorney. Guess who is? My "black sheep" middle-son conservative husband. Gee, I wonder why that would be?
But...One should be able to read Uncle Charlie’s will before you give an up or down vote on euthanasia.
That’s ‘’nice, eh?’’ :-)
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.