Posted on 06/22/2009 5:41:11 AM PDT by Kaslin
The Democrats' health care initiative reminds me of the joke about the Boy Scout fighting on a street corner with an old lady.
When a passerby asked what was going on, the scout said, "I'm trying to help her across the street but she refuses to go."
Health insurance, so far, is not mandatory by law, and we've got 16 percent of the population -- 47 million or so -- without it. Auto insurance is mandatory by law, and according to the Insurance Research Council, 14 percent of drivers nationwide still don't buy it.
Government can't make people do what they don't want to do. And it can't change human nature. Political freedom and capitalism work so well because they reflect the truth that human beings have free choice. But this means individuals take personal responsibility.
The left has always been in denial about this, which is why they're endlessly trying to expand government and reduce freedom. They see individuals as hapless victims the state must take care of.
During the presidential campaign, Barack Obama said "The reason people don't have health insurance isn't because they don't want it. It's because they can't afford it."
This is largely not true.
According to a new study from the Employment Policy Institute, authored by two economists from City University of New York (one, June O'Neill, spent four years as head of the Congressional Budget Office), 43 percent of the 47 million can afford insurance and choose not to purchase it.
According to 2007 census data, 20 percent of uninsured households earn over $75,000.
Regarding the remaining 57 percent, the authors call them "involuntarily" uninsured because they can't afford insurance. But "involuntarily" is also a misnomer, because it implies no connection in how they choose to live to the fact that they can't afford insurance.
The study provides the following portrait of this population: About a third are high school dropouts; they are disproportionately young; about a third are immigrants, mostly Hispanic non-citizens; about half are single without children; about 40 percent did not work during the year.
Pulling immigrants out of the equation, we're left with an uninsured population that can't afford insurance that is about a third the size of the widely quoted 47 million. It's a population that is generally poor, young, uneducated, and not working.
We're already set up to deal with these folks. Either through Medicaid or covering their emergency room visits. The operative question is do we want to further institutionalize this reality into a new national health care plan involving trillions in new taxes and programs.
I think the answer is clear: No.
What should we do?
A recent study by consulting firm McKinsey & Company on American education estimates our annual GDP would increase by $500 billion if the educational performance of black and Latino kids is raised to the national average. Otherwise stated, it is costing us $500 billion per year to not do this.
This dwarfs the excessive costs in health care that our president now calls our No. 1 economic problem.
It is simply not credible for Obama to propose taxing Americans trillions to subsidize health care when he refuses to come to grips with why so many are poor.
Open the door to millions of poor kids out of broken families, broken public schools, and the cycle of poverty through school choice. Give them the opportunity to go to church schools.
Rather than perpetuating poverty through further institutionalization of the welfare state, expose poor kids to the values and education necessary to enable them to make the right choices for their lives.
There is no future for a nation of victims, whether we're talking about health care or anything else. But there is a great future for a country of responsible, free people.
And anyone who thinks the uninsured don’t have health care has been to an emergency room lately.
So why do we have to now insure them?? We're picking up the tab NOW...somehow.
“...43 percent of the 47 million can afford insurance and choose not to purchase it.”
And I’ll be one of them if 0bama decrees a tax upon that employer benefit.
Jerk.
BFL reference
Of course it’s bogus. I am tired of hearing people tell me this over and over and over. Where are the solutions to getting rid of these people and their bogus junk.
Just more de facto reparations
and another power grab.
That number includes about 9.5 million illegal aliens. Anytime anyone mentions that number they need to be reminded of that fact, and then asked:
Is it really your desire to provide health insurance for people who are here illegally?
Let them choose between cable TV, cell phones or health insurance... cause you know about the “right” to have a cell phone and cable television, doncha?
How many of the uninsured have large screen high definition TVs?
Makes sense to me! Gut the current US Health care system for a mere 5% of the American population.
Very, very true. When my son developed severe pain in his hip and needed to be seen in the ER at Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, the ER was full of what I assume were uninsured kids with every form of sniffles you can imagine. They used the ER instead of a family doctor and went at the first sign of discomfort. My son, who was unable to stand and might have had a life-threatening infection, had to wait until after every single one of the sniffling kids was seen. I assume they were afraid of a discrimination lawsuit and put him last.
At 3am, we gave up on having him seen by the ER docs and took him home for a few hours sleep. In the morning we called his regular doctor, who made some calls to the hospital so that he could actually be evaluated. It was quite an education into how the system works for and against people who actually pay their bills and have insurance.
Despite in-depth assessment, the doctors never made a final determination of what was wrong, but they ruled out life threatening problems. It was probably a viral infection, and it affected other joints in the coming weeks, but not as severely. The standard of care was excellent once we got through the politically correct triage process. I hate to think what might have happened to him if he'd had a septic hip. He might well have died because of the delay.
Soap box. Ballot box. Cartridge box. Witness history (including current events in Iran).
Thank you.
Does this mean that the people who are actively on Medicaid are being counted in the supposed 47 million of uninsured?
Ms. Parker nailed it when she stated the Left has been in denial regarding this issue and only sees Americans as hapless victims that are too stupid to do for themselves, and thus need Big Government's 'help'.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.