Skip to comments.When Girls Will Be Boys
Posted on 03/17/2008 8:50:15 PM PDT by Marc Tumin
click here to read article
“I knew someone once at work whod gone through this. I cant begin to imagine the stress on them wrestling with these decisions. It was a very sad story that finally turned out for the best.”
I dunno, I’ve heard rumblings that a substantial proportion of transsexuals end up regretting their choice but that, like abortion and breast cancer, those figures are suppressed by the usual suspects. I’m willing to bet, that the cause of gender dysmorphic disorder is not so mysterious after all, that most of it’s victims, like nearly all gays, were in fact molested as very young children.
> “Mayhap if boys were raised by men and girls raised by women, this wouldnt be a problem.?” <
That’s the way they did it in ancient Greece. The result was rampant homosexuality.
But the sons haven't a clue as to where to pit it anyway.
There’s a good reason he was in the abnormal psych class.
You are not allowed to make such radical suggestions until you check in with:
That is myth. There was no “rampant” homosexuality in either ancient or Hellenistic Greece.
Sorry, Nucsubs, but as a highly trained professional Art Historian, I beg to differ.
The Greeks idealized the man-boy love relationship to such an extent that they painted the pornographic subject on pottery. Lots of pottery. There are people who collect it (no doubt for the salaciousness of the subject), and in museums it is usually kept in the storage areas accessible only to staff. We unlucky few are, ahem, exposed to it. (Sorry for the pun.)
I take it from your handle that you were in the Nuclear Sub Fleet. I was, for six years, a Navy linguist (CTI).
Among particular social and economic cadres of the ancient world, there was certainly nothing deemed wrong with homosexual liaisons under accepted protocols. On the other hand, for the vast majority of rural folk in the Mediterranean world, heterosexuality and marriage were, of course, the norms. The pre-Christian poor and agrarian classes considered homosexual acts deviant, not on religious grounds of sinfulness, but rather as proof of corruption and decadence that were the wages of too much money and too much time in town.
This is merely the one quote I could find quickly online. I have read several books by him and he makes it quite clear that homosexuality was neither "rampant" nor celebrated. It was accepted in very narrow terms and considered a pathology of the very wealthy (hence the surviving art evidence you point to and the persistence of the myth). Your argument comes from the likes of Cahill who is a liberal hack next to Hanson.
I was in from 85-92, See my profile.
> “...It was accepted in very narrow terms and considered a pathology of the very wealthy...” <
Good catch. That statement sounds like it would be closer to the “norm” for the majority who are usually voiceless. Why? Unfortunately rural folk in the ancient world didn’t write the histories - they couldn’t write much less read. To receive an education one had to have wealth - so guess who wrote the histories?
Interest in how ancient peoples lived, other than the very wealthy, has been of increasing interest during the last half of the 20th century, something I believe we Americans fostered. Personally I’m glad to see it.
Western Civilization’s classical perception of the ancient world has tended to be fixed by the interests of 18th-19th century Europeans, a group whose backgrounds were anything but middleclass. The homosexual agenda goes way back.
Thank you for the civil conversation on this subject.
The issue was not about the presence of homosexuality in Greece, it was the use of use of "rampant". It made it sound like the Greeks were all rump rangers.
They were not and most of the ones who did participate in this repulsive behavior practiced more of a pedastry with feminine looking adolescent boys, never grown men.
“Sorry Rey, but you are not a man” - The Men
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.