The copyright infringement claims stood little chance since the clips were being used for commentary about Savage, clearly fair use. But good luck on the other charges exposing CAIR as a terrorist front.
He will probably need it. It sounds as if Savage and his attorney are trying to throw everything including the kitchen sink at the organization. That can backfire and alienate a judge who has the consider every single cause of action. If Savage is the only party and he can’t prove he is the aggrieved party on each count, I can see why the judge might send it back for revision. She hasn’t kicked it completely out. He has the right to amend the complaint and get another hearing.
(Truthfully, I don’t listen to Savage lately. I got really tired of his constant anger. When one is always angry, their anger stops attracting attention and, for me, it became a real turn-off.) I think he might have some real points to score against CAIR and I hope he succeeds but he has to proceed very carefully, getting the right allegations, the right plaintiffs and defendants, the right jurisdictions and venues, the right damages or he will get kicked out permanently.