Pope Breathing on Own; No Lung Infection

Yahoo News ^ | February 25, 2005 | Victor L. Simpson

[NYer]

VATICAN CITY -

Pope John Paul (news - web sites) II is breathing on his own, but his doctors have advised him not to speak for a few days, the Vatican (news - web sites) said Friday, a day after he was rushed to a hospital and underwent surgery to ease another breathing crisis.

Papal spokesman Joaquin Navarro-Valls said the frail 84-year-old John Paul spent a restful night at Rome's Gemelli Polyclinic, where doctors said there was no sign the pope had a lung infection such as pneumonia.

The pontiff had been taken by ambulance to the hospital on Thursday after suffering his second bout of breathing trouble in less than a month. Navarro-Valls told reporters that the operation doctors performed to cut a small breathing hole in the pope's neck "was not an emergency procedure."

"It was a question of assuring adequate breathing of the patient," he said.

Italian news agencies had reported that John Paul was placed on a respirator after the surgery, but Navarro-Valls said the pope "had no need of assisted breathing."

"Assisted means mechanical, which wasn't used yesterday, nor last night, nor this morning. There was no need," he said.

John Paul had no fever, Navarro-Valls added. He said the pope's post-operative condition was progressing normally and that he was breathing better.

"The Holy Father spent a night of tranquil rest," he said. "This morning, he ate breakfast with a good appetite. He's breathing on his own and cardio-circulatory conditions remain good."

"Upon the advice of his doctors, the pope must not speak for several days, so as to favor the recovery of the functions of the larynx," Navarro-Valls said.

Navarro-Valls said the pope's breakfast included coffee with milk, 10 biscuits and yogurt. "He ate everything," the spokesman said.

The pope wrote a note Thursday night to his aides saying, "What did they do to me?" Navarro-Valls said, describing it as a joking message.

"I am always totus tuus," Navarro-Valls quoted the pope as writing. Totus tuus is John Paul's Latin motto translated by his spokesman as meaning, "I am completely in your hands."

He said the Vatican did not expect to issue another medical bulletin until Monday.

The Vatican had said late Thursday that the pontiff was conscious and "serene" after tracheotomy surgery to cut a small hole in his neck and insert a tube. Navarro-Valls said it was not clear how long the tube will remain. "The doctors will decide," he said.

Cabinet Undersecretary Gianni Letta, Premier Silvio Berlusconi's right-hand man, told reporters at Gemelli late Thursday that he'd met the pope, who appeared well. After the operation, John Paul raised his hand and attempted to speak with doctors but was told not to try, Letta said.

"I entered Gemelli very somber and sad, and I leave very satisfied," Letta said. "Doctors are very satisfied both at how he got through the operation and in these first hours of the postoperative phase."

The tracheotomy will likely have serious consequences for the pope's ability to carry on his duties. The operation would prevent him from being able to speak for an extended period and probably require a long hospital stay.

Vatican officials said on condition of anonymity that the pope — who suffers from Parkinson's disease (news - web sites) and crippling hip and knee ailments — was stricken with breathing problems similar to those that sent him to Gemelli on Feb. 1 for a 10-day stay, and Italian news reports said the latest respiratory crisis was even more severe than the first one.

An outside medical expert said the fact the pope was hooked up to a respirator was an ominous sign.

"The fact that he is on a respirator is not good. The fact that he was readmitted so quickly is not good. All this suggests there's a serious problem," said Dr. Michael Kaplitt, a Parkinson's disease expert at New York Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical Center.

Navarro-Valls said the pope had been informed of his situation and gave approval for the operation. John Paul's flu symptoms had worsened in recent days with renewed respiratory problems, leading to the decision to perform the tracheotomy, the spokesman said.

Before the operation, the pope was well enough to joke with his medical team, Letta said. When doctors told the pope that the operation would be a small one, the pope retorted: "Small, it depends for whom," according to Letta, who cited doctors' accounts.

ANSA reported that the pope was conscious when he arrived at Gemelli and that he was sitting upright in a stretcher. According to the report, people who saw him enter the hospital said he looked "quite relaxed."

The frail pontiff had greeted pilgrims twice at the window of his studio at St. Peter's Square since his release from Gemelli on Feb. 10, and on Wednesday he made his longest public appearance since falling ill more than three weeks ago.

With each successive appearance, he seemed a little stronger, a little more alert, and his voice rang out with greater clarity. That made Thursday's reversal all the more shocking for the faithful.

"We are so scared because he has been sick in the past," said Vanessa Animo Bono, 32, a Roman Catholic being treated at Gemelli.

Thursday's hospitalization was the pope's eighth since his election in 1978.

The latest hospitalization was certain to further fuel speculation about whether he could continue as pope, and what would happen if he was incapacitated.

[NYer]

Thank you all for your prayers!

[NYer]

Pope John Paul (news - web sites) II waves to faithful from a window of Rome's Agostino Gemelli hospital where he appeared Sunday, Feb. 6, 2005. Pope John Paul II was rushed to the hospital Thursday, Feb. 24, 2005, after suffering a relapse of the flu, the Vatican (news - web sites) announced, a day after the pontiff made his longest public appearance since being discharged from the clinic two weeks ago. The 84-year-old pontiff was taken to Gemelli Polyclinic hospital after the return of flu symptoms Wednesday afternoon. He was hospitalized for 'necessary specialized assistance and further tests,' papal spokesman Joaquin Navarro-Valls said. (AP Photo/Lionel Cironneau)

Catholic Ping - Come home for Easter and experience God’s merciful love. Please freepmail me if you want on/off this list

[trisham]

Wonderful news!

[CitizenM]

Just reported on FOX: (Short version) Re: the Pope’s surgery : “Local anesthetic, (not general as previously stated in the news) no pneumonia, Pope did not need a ventilator” actual report from the doctors at the hospital. Vatican said, “…Not an emergency…Pope was awake and advised about the procedure and elected to have the surgery...resting comfortably now.” Oh, what a wonderful relief!

[mike182d]

I'm sorry, but a part of me just doesn't buy it.

You don't have a "routine" tracheotomy as a patient with Parkinson's disease and the "flu."

God bless the Vatican, but I think there is a lot they're not telling us.

[DBeers]

but his doctors have advised him not to speak for a few days

He better listen to the doctors and get some rest this time!

[ohioWfan]

Praise God for answered prayer!

[sgtbono2002]

They say he doesnt have pneumonia if his lungs are clear then he couldnt get air to his lungs. Is something pinching off his trachea? A tumor? Sounds like something wrong in his throat yet he ate 10 biscuits. I hope he is fine but we arent getting the full story I dont think.

[investigateworld]

Prayers up for the good Padre.

[marshmallow]

You're right, of course. Anytime a doctor cuts a hole in your neck to allow you to breathe, it's an emergency.

I think this morning's report just means that we're back to the day to day "weak but in no immediate danger" state, rather than the hourly deathwatch which many of us assumed yesterday.

I'm coming to realize that God has His own time and plans for each of us and each day has troubles sufficient for itself, as Scripture tells us. Certainly with this Pope, he's been to death's door and back so many times that I've given up thinking "OK, this must be it, this time".

[spectre]

I seriously doubt he ate TEN biscuits...nahhhhh...someone needs to go to confession over there, LOL.

sw

[DBeers]

They say he doesnt have pneumonia if his lungs are clear then he couldnt get air to his lungs. Is something pinching off his trachea?

I saw some doctor on the news last night that stated parkinsons disease affects muscles and thus can also affect the throat muscles etcetera.

[VRWCTexan]

I have to agree - there appear to be more "spin doctors" on the case that "medical" doctors

[RayChuang88]

I still think given the Pope's current condition there is still a chance John Paul II may become the first Pope to resign his position since the 1200's, if only because he can no longer fulfill his duties as Pope. Expect a decision on this probably within the next few weeks.

[newzjunkey]

Between his parkinsons and spine problems it isn't going to be easy for him to breath. Not easy at all.

[dubyas_vision]

I seriously doubt he ate TEN biscuits...nahhhhh...someone needs to go to confession over there, LOL.

I'm wondering if "biscuit" has different meaning to the author than to us. Maybe he ate ten small cookies (British meaning of "biscuit")

[NYer]

Is something pinching off his trachea? A tumor?

If you take a good look at this picture or any other recent photograph of the Holy Father, you will notice that his back is curved. To complicate matters further, the Alzheimer's prevents him from 'clearing' his throat properly. This, compounded by the flu, has exacerbated the situation.

[NYer]

CORRECTION - "Parkinson's" not "Alzheimer's"

[Rutles4Ever]

Thank God.

[RushCrush]

Maybe they meant the small sweet biscuits you get with coffee over there.